{
 "A1_clustering": {
  "A1a_journal_cluster": {
   "clusters": 1791,
   "excludes_zero": true,
   "median_ci95": [
    -18.5,
    -7.0
   ],
   "share_faster_ci95": [
    0.5672410369143248,
    0.65847025441721
   ]
  },
  "A1b_publisher_cluster": {
   "clusters": 178,
   "excludes_zero": true,
   "median_ci95": [
    -17.5,
    -2.0
   ],
   "share_faster_ci95": [
    0.51241739403538,
    0.694009027651545
   ]
  },
  "stratum_cluster_original_method": {
   "median_ci95": [
    -17.5,
    -8.0
   ],
   "share_faster_ci95": [
    0.5774051842959278,
    0.6503428198951766
   ]
  }
 },
 "A2_mass_retraction_strata": {
  "A2a_drop_strata_10_plus": {
   "decision": "faster",
   "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
    -3.5,
    -0.5
   ],
   "median_paired_difference_days": -2.0,
   "n_journals": 1787,
   "n_retracted": 6969,
   "n_strata": 4112,
   "retracted_removed": 13530,
   "share_faster": {
    "high": 0.5288668340082018,
    "k": 3604,
    "low": 0.5054090062516773,
    "n": 6969,
    "rate": 0.5171473669106041
   },
   "share_removed": 0.6600321966925216,
   "threshold": 10
  },
  "A2b_drop_strata_5_plus": {
   "decision": "faster",
   "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
    -4.5,
    -1.0
   ],
   "median_paired_difference_days": -2.5,
   "n_journals": 1778,
   "n_retracted": 5257,
   "n_strata": 3843,
   "retracted_removed": 15242,
   "share_faster": {
    "high": 0.5346932685735412,
    "k": 2740,
    "low": 0.5076953876415405,
    "n": 5257,
    "rate": 0.5212098154841164
   },
   "share_removed": 0.7435484657788185,
   "threshold": 5
  }
 },
 "A3_reason_split": {
  "A3a_reasons_after_A2a": {
   "data_or_image_problems": {
    "decision": "no_clear_difference",
    "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
     -0.5,
     4.0
    ],
    "median_paired_difference_days": 1.5,
    "n_journals": 937,
    "n_retracted": 2939,
    "n_strata": 1984,
    "share_faster": {
     "high": 0.502254772825456,
     "k": 1423,
     "low": 0.46614311700267325,
     "n": 2939,
     "rate": 0.4841782919360327
    }
   },
   "honest_error": {
    "decision": "no_clear_difference",
    "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
     -6.5,
     4.0
    ],
    "median_paired_difference_days": -0.5,
    "n_journals": 290,
    "n_retracted": 358,
    "n_strata": 347,
    "share_faster": {
     "high": 0.554280838507467,
     "k": 180,
     "low": 0.45124644409447245,
     "n": 358,
     "rate": 0.5027932960893855
    }
   },
   "other_or_unspecified": {
    "decision": "no_clear_difference",
    "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
     -4.5,
     0.0
    ],
    "median_paired_difference_days": -2.5,
    "n_journals": 1014,
    "n_retracted": 2324,
    "n_strata": 1762,
    "share_faster": {
     "high": 0.5404852561739617,
     "k": 1209,
     "low": 0.4998955007043959,
     "n": 2324,
     "rate": 0.520223752151463
    }
   },
   "paper_mill": {
    "decision": "no_clear_difference",
    "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
     -20.0,
     2.5
    ],
    "median_paired_difference_days": -7.75,
    "n_journals": 153,
    "n_retracted": 424,
    "n_strata": 226,
    "share_faster": {
     "high": 0.596230678423942,
     "k": 233,
     "low": 0.5019365261189959,
     "n": 424,
     "rate": 0.5495283018867925
    }
   },
   "peer_review_manipulation": {
    "decision": "faster",
    "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
     -39.756249999999994,
     -23.75
    ],
    "median_paired_difference_days": -32.0,
    "n_journals": 117,
    "n_retracted": 335,
    "n_strata": 170,
    "share_faster": {
     "high": 0.8092378035415395,
     "k": 257,
     "low": 0.7190328532517369,
     "n": 335,
     "rate": 0.7671641791044777
    }
   },
   "plagiarism_or_duplication": {
    "decision": "no_clear_difference",
    "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
     -4.5,
     2.0
    ],
    "median_paired_difference_days": -1.5,
    "n_journals": 439,
    "n_retracted": 589,
    "n_strata": 535,
    "share_faster": {
     "high": 0.5528863854855183,
     "k": 302,
     "low": 0.47241548869487154,
     "n": 589,
     "rate": 0.5127334465195246
    }
   }
  },
  "A3b_paper_mill_with_peer_review_reason": {
   "decision": "faster",
   "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
    -44.0,
    -15.0
   ],
   "median_paired_difference_days": -23,
   "n_journals": 33,
   "n_retracted": 4455,
   "n_strata": 81,
   "share_faster": {
    "high": 0.8016092438010763,
    "k": 3519,
    "low": 0.7776892183342358,
    "n": 4455,
    "rate": 0.7898989898989899
   }
  },
  "A3b_paper_mill_without_peer_review_reason": {
   "decision": "slower",
   "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
    1.0,
    9.5
   ],
   "median_paired_difference_days": 6.0,
   "n_journals": 151,
   "n_retracted": 1466,
   "n_strata": 327,
   "share_faster": {
    "high": 0.47371763233667247,
    "k": 657,
    "low": 0.42286985396137017,
    "n": 1466,
    "rate": 0.4481582537517053
   }
  }
 },
 "A4_screening": {
  "after_A2a": {
   "estimated_non_retracted": 1837266,
   "estimated_non_retracted_fast": 167349,
   "non_retracted_fast_rate": 0.09108585035327035,
   "ppv_upper_bound": 0.006170275756632451,
   "retracted": 6969,
   "retracted_fast": 1039,
   "sensitivity": 0.14908882192567083,
   "strata": 4112
  },
  "all_strata": {
   "estimated_non_retracted": 2650576,
   "estimated_non_retracted_fast": 244727,
   "non_retracted_fast_rate": 0.09232967339434801,
   "ppv_upper_bound": 0.018910073332525357,
   "retracted": 20499,
   "retracted_fast": 4717,
   "sensitivity": 0.230108785794429,
   "strata": 4350
  },
  "definition": "fast = interval < 0.5 x stratum control median",
  "limit": "Analysed strata contain at least one retraction by construction, so the PPV is an upper bound for journals in general; the non-retracted arm also contains not-yet-retracted papers.",
  "years_2012_2019": {
   "estimated_non_retracted": 1140871,
   "estimated_non_retracted_fast": 110693,
   "non_retracted_fast_rate": 0.09702519516848776,
   "ppv_upper_bound": 0.008837729992205013,
   "retracted": 7014,
   "retracted_fast": 987,
   "sensitivity": 0.1407185628742515,
   "strata": 2344
  }
 },
 "R0_reproduction": {
  "leads_addendum": false,
  "median_shift_days": 0.0,
  "original_2026_10_02": {
   "cohort_frame_n": 30172,
   "controls_drawn": 150703,
   "decision": "faster",
   "inputs": {
    "cohort_frame_sha256": "07e12f2d639f16f06b4d01c8caec92a61a410108b9f730b9c230fc0253f19263",
    "control_rows_sha256": "1934b2d3c886103a075739a9e1b14e29fe65807a632c81fa4822bad361983612",
    "note": "Per-paper frozen rows stay in the git-ignored cache (plan section 9).",
    "prefix_members": 415,
    "retracted_rows_sha256": "e9115af9a2ce970b4ba5a7a407314b6ff702c030312e7476604256af0d4f9354",
    "retraction_watch_sha256": "897e8aa6580f0c2c6c1aa1c206ccc69df72961f6ac0255d5f7e17955bd4b706c"
   },
   "journal_weighted_median_days": -1.5,
   "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
    -17.5,
    -8.5
   ],
   "median_paired_difference_days": -12.5,
   "paired_retracted": 20471,
   "share_faster": 0.6154071613502027
  },
  "rerun": {
   "cohort_frame_n": 30237,
   "controls_drawn": 150982,
   "decision": "faster",
   "inputs": {
    "cohort_frame_sha256": "05177e5954ee17ecf8a8af601e92c154fee3d15dd5b24c2e256d9e7150136d78",
    "control_rows_sha256": "4599b12f1d3adfb3b2a7475b18ff48617f21823526c126f96b7279d363430d04",
    "note": "Per-paper frozen rows stay in the git-ignored cache (plan section 9).",
    "prefix_members": 415,
    "retracted_rows_sha256": "595780b2144df1455abd98f6486bf8421491576cb4d75ad19e96f4f36c02eb5d",
    "retraction_watch_sha256": "2a9f8aef18222644b14d991fcafa825240ff15f04e592b51f95aedaadd0f1845"
   },
   "journal_weighted_median_days": -1.5,
   "median_paired_difference_ci95": [
    -17.5,
    -8.0
   ],
   "median_paired_difference_days": -12.5,
   "paired_retracted": 20499,
   "share_faster": 0.6149568271623006
  }
 },
 "bootstrap_resamples": 10000,
 "parity": "pass",
 "plan": "apps/web/research/retraction-speed/addendum-plan-2026-10-09.md",
 "seed": 20261009
}
