Skip to main content
ManuSights

Journal Requirements Observatory · v1.5

Compare the instructions that change a submission package.

Choose two journals from the maintained pilot. Each card preserves the official source, date checked, and evidence status, so you can see a concrete difference without mistaking it for a recommendation or a complete checklist.

This is a practical comparison aid, not a journal fit or acceptance assessment. Verify the current publisher instructions before you submit.

Focused comparison

Put two submission paths side by side.

Use this only to identify the package-changing difference in the pilot records. It does not rate journals, estimate acceptance, or replace the live author instructions.

PhysicsOfficial page verified

Physical Review X

American Physical Society

Featured package difference

Prepare the PRX nontechnical Popular Summary and provide the research-data availability details required by Physical Review journals.

Summary for non-specialistsData statement

Checked against the PRX information-for-authors page.

Source reviewed
Open official instructions
Ecology & climateOfficial page verified

Global Change Biology

Wiley

Featured package difference

Include a data availability statement; the journal says it will cover Dryad archiving charges for published papers when authors use Dryad.

Data statement

Checked against the journal author-guidelines page.

Source reviewed
Open official instructions

How to use this responsibly

A side-by-side view is a starting point, not the final rule.

01

Follow the source

Open the live publisher page for each selected journal. It remains the administrative authority, even where the pilot record is marked verified.

02

Keep the context

The observable difference is deliberately narrow: one package-changing requirement per journal, not a complete set of author instructions.

03

Reuse with attribution

Share the generated link, briefing note, or embeddable visual with version and evidence boundaries intact. Original Manusights classifications are reusable under CC BY 4.0.