European Heart Journal 'Under Review': What Each Status Means
If your European Heart Journal submission shows Under Review, here is what the ESC Editorial Board and handling editor are doing during each stage and when to follow up.
While you wait
Waiting on European Heart Journal? Get your next move ready.
The European Heart Journal wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.
European Heart Journal review timeline: what the data shows
Time to first decision is the most actionable number. What happens after varies by manuscript and reviewer availability.
What shapes the timeline
- Use the publisher's current timing summary; do not assume a fixed desk-decision deadline.
- Editorial assignment, reviewer availability, topic, and revisions can all affect elapsed time.
- Revision and additional experiments can extend the timeline; the decision letter supplies the actual revision deadline.
What to do while waiting
- Track the record in the submission portal; a status label alone does not prove external review has begun.
- Follow the journal's status-inquiry guidance and any deadline in its correspondence.
- Prepare revision materials in parallel if you expect a revise-and-resubmit decision.
Last reviewed: 2026-10-09.
Quick answer: If your European Heart Journal submission shows "Under Review," elapsed time is the most reliable signal. The European Heart Journal general instructions give no desk-rejection rate or review-round length.
Single-center observational studies are often rejected at the desk regardless of statistical quality. Papers sent to review are evaluated by at least 2 peer reviewers with single-anonymized review.
For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a European Heart Journal submission readiness check.
Submission portal and editorial contact: European Heart Journal uses Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager submission portal. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID; the author guidelines give the current Editorial Office address. The European Heart Journal general instructions for authors cover the editorial workflow.
For broader status-tracking guidance across cardiology publishers, the Cell Press author status portal gives useful baseline patterns for reading status fields across editorial portals.
How does ESC handle a European Heart Journal submission?
European Heart Journal operates the ESC Editorial Board + handling editor + Editor-in-Chief model. All manuscripts submitted to the Journal are assessed by the Editorial Board. The senior handling editor reads the paper after Editorial Board initial assessment and evaluates cardiology-significance, methodological rigor, ESC family routing, and statistical adequacy.
European Heart Journal editorial culture is decisive: many submissions are stopped at the Editorial Board + handling editor desk screen; OUP publishes no rate. Papers that pass the European Heart Journal screen have cleared the steepest filter in ESC cardiology publishing.
What is European Heart Journal's review pipeline?
Status | What is happening | Timing |
|---|---|---|
Submitted | Administrative processing at European Heart Journal editorial office | Not published |
Editorial Board Initial Assessment | Editorial Board evaluating priority + scope + ESC family fit | Not published |
With Handling Editor | Handling editor evaluating cardiology-significance + statistical adequacy | Not published |
Editor Discussion | Internal ESC editorial team consultation for ambiguous fit | Parallel; invisible to author |
Under Review | External reviewers invited or actively reviewing (single-anonymized) | Not published |
Required Reviews Complete | Handling editor synthesizing reports | Not published |
Decision Pending | EIC making final decision on the manuscript | Not published |
Decision Sent | Reject, R&R, or accept | Check email |
What happens at the Editorial Board and handling editor desk screen?
Before the paper reaches external reviewers, the European Heart Journal Editorial Board assesses initial priority and the handling editor evaluates cardiology-significance. OUP publishes no rate for this stage.
A desk rejection can mean the Editorial Board concluded that the work would fit better at another ESC journal (European Heart Journal Open for open-access cascade, EHJ-Cardiovascular Imaging for imaging specialty, EHJ-Quality of Care and Clinical Outcomes for outcomes specialty, EHJ-Cardiovascular Pharmacotherapy for pharmacology), that the paper does not meet submission requirements, or that the cardiology-priority bar is not met. Single-center observational studies are often rejected at the desk regardless of statistical quality.
What happens during administrative processing?
The European Heart Journal editorial office confirms the files are complete: the manuscript, figures and tables as separate files (figures may be embedded at initial submission if you use format-free submission), supplementary files, the Declarations Form (disclosure of interest, data availability statement, funding, ethical approval statement, and pre-registered clinical trial number where applicable), CRediT contributor roles, and a cover letter. The author guidelines ask authors to follow reporting guidelines such as CONSORT, STROBE, and PRISMA, and clinical trials should be registered prospectively.
What happens during Editorial Board assessment?
The Editorial Board evaluates whether the submission meets European Heart Journal's priority bar and whether the paper should be considered for further review or returned (potentially with a suggestion to submit to another ESC journal). This is where desk rejection is concentrated: the Board reads for cardiology priority and ESC family fit before any handling editor invests time. A return at this stage usually reflects scope or priority, not a fatal flaw in the science, which is why many returned papers find a home at a sister ESC title.
What happens during internal ESC editorial team discussion?
In parallel with the Editorial Board's initial assessment, ambiguous-fit papers are discussed across the ESC editorial team where peer Editorial Board members weigh in on whether the paper would fit better at European Heart Journal flagship or at sister ESC journals. This editorial-team discussion runs alongside the assessment and may add time to the timeline that is invisible to the author in the portal.
What happens during the handling editor desk screen?
Papers that pass the Editorial Board initial assessment are passed to a handling editor who evaluates cardiology-significance, methodological rigor, and statistical adequacy. The handling editor oversees peer review and recommends a final decision.
What happens during external reviewer recruitment?
European Heart Journal manuscripts that pass initial assessment are typically sent to at least two reviewers. Recruitment can take time because reviewers with topic-matched cardiology subspecialty expertise (especially across interventional, electrophysiology, heart failure, prevention, and basic-translational boundaries) are scarce.
What happens during active peer review?
Once reviewers agree to review, OUP does not publish a length for the European Heart Journal peer-review cycle. Reviewers are likely to evaluate cardiology-significance, methodological rigor, statistical methodology, CONSORT compliance for clinical trials, and reproducibility.
What happens after peer review?
After reports return, the handling editor synthesizes them and recommends a final decision. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on the manuscript.
When to worry
- Early rejection: Editorial Board initial assessment rejection.
- Later early rejection: Handling editor desk rejection.
- Still Under Review after the first few weeks: Strong signal. Paper passed both the Editorial Board and handling editor filters.
- Still Under Review after 10 weeks: Reviewer-recruitment or reviewer-report delay. A polite inquiry via the Editorial Manager portal is appropriate.
- Status changes to "Decision Pending": Reports are in; the Editor-in-Chief is making the final decision.
"My paper has been Under Review for 5 weeks. Is that bad?"
This is the most common anxiety we hear from European Heart Journal authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: not by itself; OUP does not publish a review-round length. Reports may already be in editorial synthesis with the handling editor preparing the recommendation for the Editor-in-Chief. Most reviewer-driven delays come from reviewer-recruitment timing for cardiology subspecialty experts rather than slow reviews.
If the portal still says Under Review at the 8-week mark, the most likely explanation is that one of the assigned reviewers asked for an extension and the handling editor granted it. This is normal practice at European Heart Journal.
During the 5-to-8-week window, hold the status inquiry unless the manuscript record shows a technical problem, a funder or ethics disclosure changes, or a conference embargo date becomes urgent. A useful inquiry names the manuscript ID, current status, submission date, and one concrete reason you need a check; it should not ask whether the paper is likely to be accepted.
What to do while waiting
- Do not email the editorial office during the first 6 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
- Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at European Heart Journal. ESC has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
- Prepare a point-by-point response template for likely reviewer concerns: cardiology-significance, methodological rigor, statistical adequacy (anticipating single-center observational study concerns if applicable), CONSORT compliance, reproducibility.
- If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
- Read recent European Heart Journal papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.
Readiness check
While you wait on European Heart Journal, scan your next manuscript.
The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.
Status inquiry checklist
Before contacting European Heart Journal, confirm each item below:
- The manuscript has been in active review for at least 8 weeks, or the portal shows a technical inconsistency.
- The message includes the manuscript ID, article title, current status, and submission date.
- The question is limited to status or timing, not an acceptance prediction.
- Any new disclosure, preprint update, conference embargo, or related submission is described in one sentence.
- The corresponding author sends the note through Editorial Manager or the editorial-office address listed in the author guidelines.
If European Heart Journal rejects, what cascade makes sense?
If your European Heart Journal paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the reviewers and handling editor cited:
European Heart Journal Open is the natural OUP open-access cascade for cardiology papers where the priority bar of EHJ flagship is not met but the rigor is high. The ESC manuscript transfer service sends the manuscript files and any reviewer reports from consenting reviewers to the receiving journal.
EHJ-Cardiovascular Imaging is the ESC imaging specialty cascade.
EHJ-Cardiovascular Pharmacotherapy is the ESC pharmacology specialty cascade.
EHJ-Quality of Care and Clinical Outcomes is the ESC outcomes specialty cascade.
EHJ-Valvular and Structural Heart Disease is the ESC valvular specialty cascade.
Circulation is the external AHA top-tier cardiology cascade. Circulation uses ScholarOne at ScholarOne submission portal; editorial contact circ@circulationjournal.org.
JACC is the external ACC cascade for top-tier cardiology. JACC uses ScholarOne at ScholarOne submission portal; editorial contact jacc@elsevier.com.
How does European Heart Journal compare to nearby alternatives?
Feature | European Heart Journal | Circulation | JACC | European Heart Journal Open |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Desk-rejection rate | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published |
Desk-decision speed | Not published | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed |
Total review time, post-screen | Not published | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed |
Reviewer count | ≥2 (single-anonymized) | 2 to 3 + statistical | 2 to 3 + statistical | 2 to 3 |
Peer-review model | Single-anonymized + Editorial Board + handling editor | Single-blind + statistical | Single-blind + statistical | OUP open-access single-anonymized |
Editorial bar | Top ESC cardiology priority + multi-center preferred | Top AHA cardiology + statistical rigor | Top ACC cardiology + statistical rigor | OUP open-access cardiology |
Publisher-reported acceptance figures link to their source. Elsevier catalog figures were checked in October 2026; the catalog does not specify the reporting period or submission denominator.
Submit If
If your European Heart Journal paper is still Under Review after the first few weeks, you have cleared both the Editorial Board and handling editor desk screens. Use the waiting window to prepare a thorough revision response template.
European Heart Journal submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.
Think Twice If
European Heart Journal handling editors retain discretion to reject after partial review if reviewer reports surface methodological or cardiology-significance concerns the desk screen did not catch. Most post-desk-screen papers still receive a reject or substantial-revision decision.
- The abstract does not make the ESC-level cardiology consequence visible in the first half of the abstract.
- The first table, figure, or statistical supplement cannot defend sample size, event counts, adjustment strategy, and multi-center generalizability.
For a pre-upload diagnostic of cardiology-priority framing and statistical adequacy (especially for observational studies), run a European Heart Journal pre-submission diagnostic before reviewer reports surface those concerns.
Last verified: European Heart Journal general instructions at Oxford Academic author instructions and OUP ESC editorial documentation.
What do European Heart Journal reviewers evaluate?
Reviewers at European Heart Journal are likely to focus on four things. The author instructions do not list a reviewer checklist, so the table below is a Manusights reading of what matters, mapped to actionable preparation.
Reviewer focus area | What reviewers are likely to evaluate | How to prepare for it |
|---|---|---|
Cardiology priority | Does the work matter for the ESC cardiology readership beyond a narrow subspecialty? | Frame the introduction around the broader-cardiology priority the findings address. Papers without clear cardiology priority are the ones stopped at the screen. |
Statistical adequacy | Are the statistical methods appropriate, with adequate sample size and multi-center design where applicable? | Single-center observational studies are often rejected at the desk regardless of statistical quality. Multi-center design or pooled analysis dramatically improves acceptance odds. |
CONSORT / STROBE compliance | Does the manuscript comply with CONSORT (clinical trials) or STROBE (observational studies) reporting standards? | Complete the relevant reporting checklist fully before submission. Reviewers consistently flag checklist gaps. |
Reproducibility | Could the central cardiology analyses be reproduced by another team with the methods as written? | Use detailed methods documentation. European Heart Journal requires data-availability statements. Pre-registration documentation strengthens reproducibility framing. |
What patterns miss the European Heart Journal bar?
In our pre-submission work with European Heart Journal-targeted manuscripts, three named patterns generate the most consistent reviewer concerns and the most common reasons papers miss the editorial bar or fail the desk screen.
Single-center observational design flagged at Editorial Board screen. When the work is a single-center observational study without multi-center validation or pooled analysis, Editorial Board desk rejection is common (single-center observational studies are often rejected at the desk regardless of statistical quality). The strongest manuscripts include multi-center validation or pooled analysis.
Check your European Heart Journal study design →
Narrow-subspecialty framing flagged at desk screen. When the introduction frames the work too narrowly within one cardiology subspecialty without broader-cardiology priority, handling editor desk rejection is common. The strongest manuscripts frame the broader cardiology relevance.
Check your ESC-level framing →
ESC family cascade offers from Editorial Board. When the Editorial Board concludes the work is rigorous but the cardiology priority bar of EHJ flagship is not met, transfer offers to European Heart Journal Open (open-access) or sister EHJ specialty journals are common. ESC editors take these transfers seriously.
Check if EHJ or an ESC sister title is the better target →
We have reviewed 50+ manuscripts targeting European Heart Journal, Circulation, JACC, and JAMA Cardiology. Full Manusights reviews include a 60-day money-back guarantee, and we do not train models on your manuscript.
In our pre-submission review work across cardiology targets, we see five recurring preventable risks before peer review: an abstract that hides the clinical consequence, a first table that weakens the event-count story, under-explained statistical adjustment, limited multi-center generalizability, and an ESC family routing mismatch. Source limitation: official guidance explains submission rules and editorial workflow, but it cannot diagnose whether your abstract, first figure or table, methods appendix, reporting package, and cover letter satisfy European Heart Journal's priority bar.
Methodology note
This page was created from OUP's public European Heart Journal general instructions at Oxford Academic author instructions, the single-anonymized peer review, Editorial Board + handling editor + EIC final-decision workflow described in the general instructions, and Manusights pre-submission review experience with EHJ-targeted manuscripts.
What to read next
For the cardiology landscape beyond European Heart Journal, see European Heart Journal Open (OUP open-access cascade), EHJ-Cardiovascular Imaging (imaging specialty), EHJ-Cardiovascular Pharmacotherapy (pharmacology specialty), EHJ-Quality of Care and Clinical Outcomes (outcomes specialty), EHJ-Valvular and Structural Heart Disease (valvular specialty), and external cardiology alternatives (Circulation, JACC, JAMA Cardiology, Lancet).
The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is top ESC cardiology (EHJ), OUP open-access cardiology (EHJ Open), specialty ESC scope (sister EHJ journals), top AHA cardiology (Circulation), top ACC cardiology (JACC), top AMA cardiology (JAMA Cardiology), or top global-impact (Lancet).
Reviewers at European Heart Journal typically include at least 2 cardiology subspecialty experts under a single-anonymized model. Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any reviewer sees them, and preparing a response template that addresses both cardiology-priority and statistical-adequacy perspectives accelerates revision rounds substantially.
For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the European Heart Journal cardiology-priority-plus-statistical-rigor bar before submission, our European Heart Journal pre-submission diagnostic flags the framing and statistical weaknesses most likely to surface in reviewer reports.
Frequently asked questions
Your manuscript has cleared European Heart Journal Editorial Manager admin checks and is being evaluated. All manuscripts submitted to the Journal are assessed by the Editorial Board. Once a submitted manuscript passes initial assessment, it will then be passed to a handling editor who oversees peer review and recommends a final decision, with the Editor-in-Chief making the final decision on the manuscript.
OUP does not publish a desk-rejection rate or a review-round length for European Heart Journal. Single-center observational studies are often rejected at the desk regardless of statistical quality. Papers sent to review are evaluated by at least 2 peer reviewers.
Our advice is to wait at least 6 weeks before inquiring. Contact via the European Heart Journal Editorial Manager portal at the official submission portal referencing your manuscript ID; the author guidelines give the current Editorial Office address.
Not by itself. OUP does not publish a review-round length. Reports may already be in editorial synthesis with the handling editor preparing the recommendation for the Editor-in-Chief.
Your paper passed the Editorial Board initial assessment and was passed to a handling editor who invited at least 2 peer reviewers under the single-anonymized peer-review process. The Journal operates single-anonymized peer review, meaning reviewers know author identities while authors do not see reviewer identities.
Often. OUP does not publish a submission-to-acceptance time for the journal.
Our advice is a polite inquiry once the paper has been Under Review for 10 weeks. Silence in the first 6 weeks is normal at European Heart Journal given the multi-stage ESC editorial workflow.
Sources
Free guide
Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.
Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.
Final step
Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.
The European Heart Journal decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.
Free scan, no card needed.
Target journal European Heart Journal
Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.
Re-read the status guidePut the guidance to work
Turn a decision into a clear next step.
Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.
Where to go next
Start here
Same journal, next question
- European Heart Journal Review Time: What Authors Can Actually Expect
- EHJ Submit: European Heart Journal Submission Process (2026)
- How to Avoid Desk Rejection at European Heart Journal (2026)
- Is European Heart Journal a Good Journal? The ESC Flagship, Decoded
- Rejected from European Heart Journal? The 7 Best Journals to Submit Next
- European Heart Journal Impact Factor 2026: 45.3, Rank 2/237