Skip to main content

IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging 'Under Review': Status Meanings

If your IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging submission shows Under Review, here is what the IEEE Associate Editor is doing during each stage and when to follow up.

Editorial processThe Manusights editorial team researches and maintains these guides using source review, field-specific analysis, and our documented editorial process.How we work

While you wait

Waiting on a decision? Get your next move ready.

The wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.What the status means

Last reviewed: 2026-10-09.

Quick answer: If your IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging submission shows "Under Review," elapsed time is the most reliable signal. IEEE TMI has a 2025 Journal Impact Factor of 12.4 in the 2026 JCR release, reports an accept ratio of 10.2% over the prior 12 months, and enforces a 10-page initial-submission limit that includes references (per IEEE TMI journal statistics and the IEEE TMI instructions to authors).

TMI reports an average of 35.0 days from submission to first decision (its author instructions say about 7 weeks) and allows reviewers three weeks, extendable by up to two weeks per request. TMI publishes methodology, not pure clinical applications: manuscripts that apply existing deep-learning architectures to new medical-imaging tasks without introducing methodological advances generate consistent rejections.

For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging submission readiness check.

Submission portal and editorial contact: IEEE TMI uses the IEEE Author Portal, where status appears under Author, Manuscripts I have Co-authored. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID and go to the editorial office listed on the TMI editorial board page. The IEEE TMI instructions to authors and IEEE TMI home cover the editorial workflow. For broader status-tracking guidance, the Cell Press author status portal gives useful baseline patterns.

How IEEE handles a TMI submission

IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging is sponsored by the Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, the Signal Processing Society, the Nuclear and Plasma Sciences Society, and the Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control Society, and its editorial board lists an Editor-in-Chief, Deputy Editors-in-Chief, Senior Area Editors, and Associate Editors. The handling Associate Editor reads the entire paper and evaluates medical imaging methodology significance, comparison to state-of-the-art rigor, page-limit compliance (strict 10-page initial submission including references), and TMI subspecialty routing across image reconstruction, image segmentation, image registration, computational imaging, and machine learning for medical imaging.

IEEE TMI editorial culture is decisive: out-of-scope papers are returned with an immediate reject within two weeks and page-limit non-compliance triggers return without review. Papers that pass the IEEE TMI Associate Editor screen have cleared the steepest filter in IEEE medical imaging publishing.

What is IEEE TMI's review pipeline?

Status
What is happening
Typical duration (TMI figures where published)
Submitted
Administrative Checklist and page-limit check; papers that violate the submission policy are unsubmitted by the editorial office
No TMI figure published
With Associate Editor
Associate Editor evaluating methodology fit + page-limit compliance; may recommend an immediate reject
TMI says out-of-scope papers are returned within two weeks
AE assigns reviewers
The Associate Editor is inviting reviewers, but fewer than four have agreed (TMI's recommended number)
TMI reports about 15.9 days on average to assign reviewers (original submissions)
Waiting for Reviewers' Scores
One or more agreed reviewers have not submitted scores; reviewers have three weeks from accepting, extendable by up to two weeks per request
TMI reports about 21.2 days average reviewer turnaround
Decision
Associate Editor recommendation, then a decision letter from the Editor-in-Chief: Accept, Accept with Minor Revision, Reject with Invitation to Resubmit, or Reject
TMI reports 35.0 days on average from submission to first decision (prior 12 months); check email

What happens at the IEEE TMI Associate Editor screen?

Before the paper reaches external reviewers, an IEEE TMI Associate Editor evaluates whether the methodology significance and page-limit compliance warrant IEEE TMI's editorial slots. TMI's author instructions say its desk rejection rate is around 70%.

A desk rejection most often means the Associate Editor concluded that the work is pure clinical application without methodology contribution (TMI publishes methodology, not pure applications), exceeds the strict 10-page initial-submission limit (including references), applies existing deep-learning architectures to new medical-imaging tasks without introducing methodological advances, reports results on bespoke datasets without standardized comparison, or would fit better at a sister IEEE journal (IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, IEEE Transactions on Medical Robotics and Bionics).

What happens at the IEEE TMI administrative check?

The IEEE TMI editorial office applies an Administrative Checklist: a single PDF with figures embedded within the strict 10-page initial-submission limit (including references), TMI template formatting, accurate co-author e-mail addresses, no co-author on TMI's Prohibited Author List, and prior-review or conference-extension disclosure where applicable. A paper that violates the submission policy is unsubmitted by the editorial office. TMI strongly discourages cover letters unless the paper underwent prior review or extends a conference paper.

What happens when the Associate Editor reads the paper at IEEE TMI?

The handling Associate Editor reads the paper and evaluates medical imaging methodology significance, comparison to state-of-the-art rigor, standardized benchmark coverage, page-limit compliance, and TMI subspecialty routing.

What happens if IEEE TMI editors discuss fit?

In parallel with the Associate Editor's primary read, TMI's instructions to Associate Editors describe that when an Associate Editor is unsure whether to recommend Reject or Immediate Reject, an additional Associate Editor or a Senior Area Editor gives input, and the Managing Editor can forward an uncertain case to the Editor-in-Chief. This consultation is invisible to the author in the portal.

What happens during IEEE TMI reviewer recruitment?

TMI's instructions require Associate Editors to invite at least four reviewers within three days of being assigned a manuscript, and recommend basing the decision on at least four reviews (at least three at the minimum). TMI reports about 15.9 days on average to assign reviewers for original submissions.

What happens during IEEE TMI active peer review?

TMI allows reviewers three weeks from the day they accept the invitation, extendable by up to two weeks per request, and reports about 21.2 days average reviewer turnaround for original submissions. Reviewers are asked to evaluate methodology significance, comparison to state-of-the-art rigor, benchmark coverage adequacy, and reproducibility.

What happens after the reviews return at IEEE TMI?

After reports return, the Associate Editor synthesizes them. TMI says the duration of an individual submission can vary drastically because many factors are involved in the review process. TMI does not publish total submission-to-acceptance time.

When to worry

  • Return within days of upload: Page-limit non-compliance (exceeds strict 10-page initial submission including references) or an administrative issue; TMI says papers over 10 pages are returned without review and policy violations are unsubmitted.
  • Rejection within about two weeks: An out-of-scope paper returned with an immediate reject (TMI says this happens within two weeks), consistent with TMI's stated desk rejection rate of around 70%.
  • Still Under Review after a few weeks: Likely past the desk screen, though TMI does not publish a stage-by-stage schedule.
  • More than 7 weeks: TMI's instructions say to contact the editorial office if the review duration is abnormally long, for example more than 7 weeks, quoting your manuscript ID.
  • Status shows "Waiting for Reviewers' Scores": One or more agreed reviewers have not submitted; TMI allows three weeks, extendable by up to two weeks per request.

"My paper has been Under Review for 8 weeks. Is that bad?"

TMI's own figures put the average first decision at 35.0 days (about 5 weeks), and its author instructions say about 7 weeks, so 8 weeks is past the average, but individual reviews vary widely and reports may still be arriving.

Most reviewer-driven delays come from reviewers who ask for extensions: TMI allows up to two extra weeks per request, and an Associate Editor sometimes has to send several rounds of invitations to secure reviewers. If the portal still says Under Review well past 8 weeks, one or more assigned reviewers may have asked for an extension.

TMI's instructions say to contact the editorial office when review is abnormally long, for example more than 7 weeks, and to include your manuscript ID; it can only respond to inquiries about submissions it deems abnormally delayed. What you should NOT do is send revised files: TMI says it cannot replace or correct files once a manuscript has been assigned to an Associate Editor.

What to do while waiting

  • Do not email the editorial office before the review is abnormally long (TMI suggests more than 7 weeks) unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
  • Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at IEEE TMI. IEEE has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
  • Prepare a point-by-point response template for likely reviewer concerns: methodology significance, comparison to state-of-the-art (anticipating requests for additional recent baselines), standardized medical imaging benchmark coverage, reproducibility (anticipating requests for code release).
  • If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
  • Read recent IEEE TMI papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.

Readiness check

While you wait, scan your next manuscript.

The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.Open status guide

If IEEE TMI rejects: sister-journal cascade with reasoning

If your IEEE TMI paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the reviewers and Associate Editor cited:

IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics is the natural IEEE EMBS cascade for biomedical informatics papers.

IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering is the IEEE EMBS cascade for biomedical engineering papers.

IEEE Transactions on Medical Robotics and Bionics is the IEEE EMBS cascade for medical robotics.

IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence (TPAMI) is the IEEE Computer Society cascade for pattern analysis methodology. TPAMI uses ScholarOne at ScholarOne submission portal; editorial contact tpami@computer.ieee.org.

Medical Image Analysis (Elsevier) is the external Elsevier medical imaging cascade. Medical Image Analysis uses Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager submission portal; editorial contact mia@elsevier.com.

MICCAI conference proceedings (Springer) is the external Springer MICCAI conference cascade.

How IEEE TMI compares to nearby alternatives

Feature
IEEE TMI
IEEE TPAMI
Medical Image Analysis (Elsevier)
IEEE J Biomedical and Health Informatics
Desk-rejection rate
Around 70 percent (per TMI)
Not published
Not published
Not published
Desk-decision speed
Out-of-scope papers returned within two weeks (per TMI)
1 to 3 weeks
1 to 3 weeks
1 to 3 weeks
Total review time (post-screen)
35.0 days average to first decision (per TMI)
8 to 16 weeks (3-reviewer model)
8 to 16 weeks
8 to 12 weeks
Reviewer count
4 recommended, minimum 2 (per TMI)
3 (IEEE CS advocates 3)
2 to 3
2 to 3
Peer-review model
Single-blind (per TMI) + 10-page initial limit
IEEE double-blind + 3 reviewers
Elsevier single-anonymized
IEEE single-blind
Editorial bar
Top medical imaging methodology + strict page limit
Top pattern analysis methodology + benchmark coverage
Elsevier medical image analysis
IEEE biomedical informatics

Submit If

If your IEEE TMI paper is Under Review past the first weeks, you have most likely cleared the Associate Editor desk screen. Use the waiting window to prepare a thorough revision response template anticipating multi-reviewer methodology feedback.

IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.

Think Twice If

IEEE TMI Associate Editors retain discretion to reject after partial review if reviewer reports surface methodology or benchmark-coverage concerns the desk screen did not catch. TMI's 10.2% accept ratio over the prior 12 months means most post-desk-screen papers still receive a substantial-revision or reject decision.

  • Your PDF is over the 10-page initial-submission limit including references, or the related-work section consumes space that should prove the methodology contribution.
  • Your introduction applies a familiar neural network, reconstruction method, or registration pipeline to a clinical task without naming the reusable medical-imaging-method advance.
  • Your experiments rely on one private or bespoke dataset without a public benchmark, external validation, ablation, calibration analysis, or reproducibility package.

Check whether your IEEE TMI methodology claim is visible →

Check if your IEEE TMI benchmark and page-limit package is reviewer-ready →

Check your IEEE TMI medical-imaging routing plan →

For a pre-upload diagnostic of medical imaging methodology framing and page-limit compliance (strict 10-page initial-submission limit including references), run a IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging pre-submission diagnostic before reviewer reports surface those concerns.

IEEE TMI Status Inquiry Checklist

  • [ ] Confirm the manuscript ID, original submission date, and last Author Portal status-change date.
  • [ ] Compare elapsed time with the IEEE TMI submission guide and nearby IEEE status pages before deciding whether the wait is abnormal.
  • [ ] Recheck page count, contribution statement, benchmark coverage, code/data availability, ablations, calibration, and prior-conference disclosure.
  • [ ] Prepare a concise inquiry only after the review has passed TMI's abnormally-long mark (for example more than 7 weeks), and send it to the editorial office with the manuscript ID.

This guide tells you what IEEE TMI editors look for while a manuscript is Under Review. The review tells you whether your paper passes the methodology, page-limit, benchmark, and reproducibility checks before reviewers ask for additional experiments. Manusights has reviewed 50+ medical-imaging, computer-vision, and biomedical-engineering manuscripts, offers a 60-day money-back guarantee on paid reviews, and we do not train AI on private author manuscripts.

Last verified 2026-10-09: IEEE TMI instructions to authors, journal statistics, and peer review pages at ieeetmi.org.

IEEE TMI checklist check: for medical-imaging studies with clinical data, attach only the reporting checklist that matches the design, such as CONSORT for randomized trials, STROBE for observational cohorts, PRISMA for systematic reviews, or STARD for diagnostic-accuracy claims. For most TMI methodology papers, the more important reviewer artifact is a compact reproducibility package: dataset provenance, train/test splits, preprocessing code, hyperparameters, ablations, calibration or error analysis, and any patient-privacy limits on data release.

The IEEE TMI reviewer experience

TMI's published key criteria for regular papers are novelty, quality, appropriateness, and impact. The table below maps the review focus areas we see in practice to actionable preparation.

Reviewer focus area
What reviewers tend to evaluate
How to prepare for it
Medical imaging methodology significance
Does the work advance medical imaging methodology (not pure clinical application)?
Frame the introduction around the methodology contribution. TMI publishes methodology, not pure clinical applications.
Comparison to state-of-the-art
Does the work comprehensively compare to state-of-the-art with recent baselines?
Include comprehensive comparison to recent state-of-the-art baselines (within the last 1 to 2 years).
Standardized medical imaging benchmark coverage
Does the work include benchmark results on standardized medical imaging datasets?
Include standardized benchmark results. Papers that report results on bespoke datasets without standardized comparison draw closer reviewer scrutiny.
Page-limit compliance + reproducibility
Does the manuscript respect the strict 10-page initial-submission limit including references? Could another team reproduce the methodology with the code as written?
Use the IEEE TMI 10-page limit strictly. Release code in public repositories.

What we see in our pre-submission review work at IEEE TMI

Across IEEE TMI-targeted manuscripts, and across Manusights review data from 50+ medical-imaging, computer-vision, and biomedical-engineering manuscripts, three named patterns generate the most consistent reviewer concerns and the most common reasons papers miss the editorial bar or fail the desk screen.

Page-limit non-compliance flagged at administrative check. When the manuscript exceeds the strict 10-page initial-submission limit including references, IEEE TMI returns the paper at the administrative check. A typical CS/EE-style 12-page paper with a long related-work section gets returned before an Associate Editor can evaluate the science. The strongest manuscripts use the introduction and first method figure to make the medical-imaging contribution visible without spending pages on generic deep-learning background.

Pure-application framing without methodology contribution flagged at Associate Editor desk screen. When the work applies existing deep-learning architectures to new medical-imaging tasks without introducing methodological advances, IEEE TMI rejection is common. The strongest manuscripts state the reusable method in the title, abstract, contribution paragraph, and experiments, then connect the method to medical-imaging-specific constraints such as scarce labels, domain shift, registration uncertainty, modality fusion, or scanner/site variation.

Bespoke-dataset framing flagged as reviewer concerns. When the work reports results on bespoke datasets without standardized comparison, reviewers consistently flag concerns. The strongest IEEE TMI submissions include public or multi-site benchmarks, recent baselines, ablation studies, calibration or error analysis, code/data availability language, and a clear explanation of what cannot be shared because of patient privacy or institutional constraints.

We also check whether the cover letter and manuscript tell the same methodology story, because IEEE TMI reviewers are quick to separate a reusable imaging method from a private clinical deployment.

Source limitation: this guidance combines official guidance, public status and timing signals, and anonymized Manusights pre-submission review patterns; it does not use private IEEE editorial records. Compared with official guidance, the useful reader-facing value is translating the status into page-limit, contribution-statement, benchmark, reproducibility, and IEEE routing checks authors can act on while waiting.

Methodology note

This page was created from the public IEEE TMI instructions to authors, journal statistics, and peer review pages at ieeetmi.org (strict 10-page initial-submission limit including references, 35.0-day average to first decision, three-week reviewer allowance, methodology-not-applications focus), and Manusights pre-submission review experience with IEEE TMI-targeted manuscripts. The benchmark-coverage expectation is Manusights analysis, not a TMI rule.

For the IEEE medical imaging landscape beyond IEEE TMI, start with the IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging journal overview, the IEEE TMI submission guide, the IEEE TPAMI status guide, and the International Journal of Computer Vision status guide.

Then compare IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics (biomedical informatics), IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering (biomedical engineering), IEEE Transactions on Medical Robotics and Bionics (medical robotics), IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence (pattern analysis), and external medical imaging alternatives (Medical Image Analysis from Elsevier, MICCAI conference proceedings from Springer).

The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is top medical imaging methodology (IEEE TMI), biomedical informatics (IEEE J Biomedical and Health Informatics), biomedical engineering (IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering), medical robotics (IEEE Transactions on Medical Robotics and Bionics), pattern analysis (IEEE TPAMI), Elsevier medical image analysis (Medical Image Analysis), or MICCAI conference (MICCAI proceedings).

TMI recommends four reviewers per paper (at least two are required) under its single-blind model. Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any external reviewer sees them, and preparing a response template that addresses methodology significance, benchmark coverage, and reproducibility accelerates revision rounds substantially.

For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the IEEE TMI methodology-plus-benchmark-plus-page-limit bar before submission, our IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging pre-submission diagnostic flags the page-limit and methodology weaknesses most likely to surface in the Associate Editor desk screen.

Frequently asked questions

Your manuscript has passed IEEE TMI's initial screening and is being evaluated. In the Author Portal, Under Review covers editorial review as well as potential external peer review; TMI also explains two statuses, AE assigns reviewers (fewer than four reviewers have agreed) and Waiting for Reviewers' Scores (one or more agreed reviewers have not submitted). TMI's 10-page initial-submission limit includes references, so a 12-page paper with a long related-work section is returned without review. TMI publishes methodology, not pure clinical applications.

TMI reports an average of 35.0 days from submission to first decision (prior 12 months, journal statistics page updated June 17, 2026); its author instructions say about 7 weeks. TMI allows reviewers three weeks from accepting, extendable by up to two weeks per request. Manuscripts that apply existing deep-learning architectures to new medical-imaging tasks without introducing methodological advances generate consistent rejections.

TMI's instructions say to contact its editorial office if the review duration is abnormally long, for example more than 7 weeks, and to include your TMI manuscript ID; it can only respond to inquiries about submissions it deems abnormally delayed. Contact details are on the TMI editorial board page.

Possibly. TMI's own figures put the average first decision at about 5 to 7 weeks, and its instructions treat more than 7 weeks as abnormally long, so 8 weeks is past the average. Individual reviews vary widely, and reports may still be arriving.

The Associate Editor has started selecting and inviting reviewers, but fewer than four reviewers have agreed, which is the number TMI recommends. The status stays unchanged until four have agreed, even while the Associate Editor keeps recruiting. TMI uses single-blind peer review: reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors.

It is longer than TMI's published averages (35.0 days to first decision and 37.2 days to final decision over the prior 12 months), though individual reviews vary. TMI does not publish total submission-to-acceptance time.

TMI's instructions suggest contacting the editorial office when review takes abnormally long, for example more than 7 weeks, and it replies only about submissions it deems abnormally delayed. TMI notes that individual reviews can vary drastically because many factors are involved.

References

Sources

  1. IEEE TMI Statement of Editorial Policy
  2. IEEE TMI Information for Authors PDF
  3. IEEE TMI home
  4. Transactions on Medical Imaging - IEEE NPSS
  5. IEEE TMI SciRev community data

Free guide

Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.

Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.

The guide, plus the weekly brief on getting published. One email on Mondays and a product note at most once a month, unsubscribe in one click.

Final step

Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.

The decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.

Free scan, no card needed.

Check my next manuscript

Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.

Re-read the status guide

Put the guidance to work

Turn a decision into a clear next step.

Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.

Internal navigation

Where to go next