Nature Methods 'Under Review': What Each Status Means
If your Nature Methods submission shows Under Review, here is what Nature Portfolio editors are doing during each stage and when to follow up.
While you wait
Waiting on Nature Methods? Get your next move ready.
The Nature Methods wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.
Nature Methods review timeline: what the data shows
Time to first decision is the most actionable number. What happens after varies by manuscript and reviewer availability.
What shapes the timeline
- Use the publisher's current timing summary; do not assume a fixed desk-decision deadline.
- Editorial assignment, reviewer availability, topic, and revisions can all affect elapsed time.
- Revision and additional experiments can extend the timeline; the decision letter supplies the actual revision deadline.
What to do while waiting
- Track the record in the submission portal; a status label alone does not prove external review has begun.
- Follow the journal's status-inquiry guidance and any deadline in its correspondence.
- Prepare revision materials in parallel if you expect a revise-and-resubmit decision.
*Last reviewed: 2026-10-08.
*
Quick answer: If your Nature Methods submission shows "Under Review," elapsed time is the most reliable signal. Nature Methods has a 2025 Journal Impact Factor of 28.2 in the 2026 JCR release, and Nature Methods reports a median of 10 days from submission to first editorial decision (per Nature Methods journal metrics).
Authors report a 9.7-day average to the first editorial decision via the Nature Methods Review Speed system. Authors report 56 days to the first revision report.
Use this guide to interpret the nature methods under review status, decide whether the wait is normal, and prepare the benchmarking, biological-demonstration, and code-reproducibility package most likely to matter if reviewer reports arrive.
For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a Nature Methods submission readiness check.
What submission portal does Nature Methods use?
Nature Methods uses the Nature Portfolio submission system at the Nature Methods manuscript tracking system. You can check the status of your manuscript in the same system after submission. For general editorial inquiries or manuscript status questions, the journal lists methods@us.nature.com; include the manuscript ID.
Nature Methods editors each cover specific areas of research (the journal's editors page lists each editor's remit), so your paper is assigned to an editor with relevant expertise. The editorial team consults across areas for cross-cutting methods papers.
How Nature Portfolio handles a Nature Methods submission
Nature Methods operates the Nature Portfolio handling editor model. Per the Nature Methods editorial-process page, the manuscript is assigned to an editor, who reads the paper, consults with the editorial team, and decides whether to send it for peer review; the journal reports a median of 10 days from submission to first editorial decision.
Nature Portfolio editorial culture at Nature Methods is decisive: the 10-day median first decision (9.7-day author-reported average) and a 2026 Nature Methods editorial's report that about 87% of 2025 submissions were rejected without peer review mean most rejections happen at the handling editor read in the first weeks. Papers that pass the handling editor stage have cleared the steepest filter at Nature Portfolio's specialty methods title.
Nature Methods's review pipeline
Status | What is happening | Typical duration |
|---|---|---|
Submitted | Administrative processing at Nature Portfolio editorial office | Day 0 to 3 |
With Editor | Lead editor evaluating desk-screen fit and method advance | Days 3 to 10 |
Editor Discussion | Internal Nature Methods editor consultation for ambiguous fit cases | Days 5 to 10 (parallel; invisible to author) |
Under Review | External reviewers invited or actively reviewing | Days 10 to 56 |
Reports Received | Lead editor synthesizing reports | 7 to 14 days |
Decision Sent | Reject, R&R, or accept | Check email |
The stage labels and durations in this table are Manusights estimates, not journal-published figures.
The handling editor desk screen (about 87 percent rejected without peer review in 2025)
Before the paper reaches external reviewers, a Nature Portfolio handling editor at Nature Methods evaluates whether the method advance and biological demonstration warrant Nature Methods's selective editorial slots. A 2026 Nature Methods editorial says about 87% of 2025 submissions were rejected without peer review, and the journal reports a median of 10 days from submission to first editorial decision. A desk rejection most often means the handling editor concluded that the method advance is incremental or that the biological demonstration is insufficient to justify Nature Methods's selectivity.
Day 0 to 3: Administrative processing
The journal's editorial assistant checks that the manuscript and associated materials are complete: the manuscript file (including Methods and figures), the cover letter, optional supplementary information, and, where applicable, the reporting summary, a code-availability statement for custom code central to the paper, and a data-availability statement.
Days 3 to 10: Lead editor desk screen
The handling editor reads the paper and evaluates the method advance, biological demonstration depth, and wide relevance to method-developer audiences. The journal reports a median of 10 days from submission to first editorial decision.
Days 5 to 10: Internal editor discussion (parallel for ambiguous cases)
In parallel with the handling editor's primary read, the editor consults with the editorial team on ambiguous-fit papers, and on occasion may consult expert researchers when deciding whether to review a paper (per the editorial-process page). This editorial-team discussion runs alongside the desk-screen and is invisible to the author in the portal.
Days 10 to 21: External reviewer recruitment
Nature Portfolio handling editors at Nature Methods typically invite two to three external reviewers, sometimes more if special advice is needed. The recruitment window can take 7 to 14 days because methods reviewers with topic-matched expertise (e.g., imaging-method specialists, computational-method experts, single-cell-method developers) are scarce.
Days 14 to 56: Active peer review
Once reviewers agree to review, Nature Portfolio asks them to respond promptly within the number of days agreed with the editor (per the Nature Methods peer-review policy). The author-reported 56-day first-revision-report average reflects reviewer-extension reality across the typical recruitment-plus-review cycle.
Day 56 onward: Editorial synthesis and decision
After both reports return, the handling editor synthesizes them. In the best-case scenario, the process from submission to acceptance will take just a few months, but the journal's reported median from submission to acceptance is 276 days. Occasionally papers go through multiple revisions over a year or more.
When to worry
- Rejection within 1 to 3 days: Administrative issue or immediate scope mismatch.
- Rejection within 3 to 10 days: Lead editor desk rejection. Most rejections happen here, consistent with the 10-day median.
- Still Under Review after 2 weeks: Strong signal. Paper passed the steepest Nature Portfolio filter.
- Still Under Review after 10 weeks: Reviewer-recruitment or reviewer-report delay. A polite inquiry via the submission portal is appropriate.
- Status changes to "Reports Received": Reports are in; expect a decision within 1 to 2 weeks.
"My paper has been Under Review for 5 weeks. Is that bad?"
This is the most common anxiety we hear from Nature Methods authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: no, 5 weeks at Under Review is normal mid-cycle given the author-reported 9.7-day first-decision average and 56-day first-revision-report average. Reports may already be in editorial synthesis with the handling editor preparing a recommendation. Most reviewer-driven delays come from reviewer-recruitment timing for methods specialists rather than slow reviews.
If the portal still says Under Review at the 8-week mark, the most likely explanation is that one of the assigned reviewers asked for an extension and the handling editor granted it. This is normal practice at Nature Portfolio.
What you should NOT do during the 5-to-8-week window is email the editorial office. Handling editors at Nature Methods are managing many active papers; an inquiry at 5 weeks adds friction without accelerating the timeline.
What to do while waiting
- Do not contact the editorial office during the first 8 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
- Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at Nature Methods. Nature Portfolio has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
- Prepare a point-by-point response template for likely reviewer concerns: method advance over prior art, biological demonstration depth, code availability and reproducibility.
- If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
- Read recent Nature Methods papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.
Readiness check
While you wait on Nature Methods, scan your next manuscript.
The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.
If Nature Methods rejects: sister-journal cascade with reasoning
If your Nature Methods paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the reviewers and handling editor cited:
Nature Communications is the most natural Nature Portfolio cascade because Nature Portfolio supports manuscript transfer and the original reviewer reports are shared with the receiving journal, preserving substantial peer-review work. Nature Communications has a broader scope and an open-access publishing model.
Nature Biotechnology is a Nature Portfolio cascade option for biotechnology-method papers where the technology advance is stronger than the biological demonstration framing.
Communications Biology is a Nature Portfolio open-access option for technically rigorous methods papers where the broader-methods audience appeal is narrower than Nature Methods's bar.
Bioinformatics or eLife Methods are independent cascade options for computational-method papers where Nature Methods's biology-demonstration requirement is too strict. eLife reviews under public preprint conditions.
How Nature Methods compares to nearby alternatives
Feature | Nature Methods | Nature Biotechnology | Nature Communications | Bioinformatics |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Desk-rejection rate | About 87 percent (2025, journal editorial) | Not published | 72.5% rejected outright (March 2015 to February 2017) | Not published |
Desk-decision speed | 10 days median (journal-reported) | 3 to 14 days | 3 to 14 days | 14 to 21 days |
Total review time (post-screen) | 4 to 12 weeks | 4 to 12 weeks | 6 to 12 weeks | 4 to 8 weeks |
Reviewer count | 2 to 3 | 2 to 3 | 2 to 3 | 2 to 3 |
Peer-review model | Reviewers anonymous to authors; optional double-anonymized review | Nature transparent (optional) | Nature transparent (mandatory) | OUP standard |
Editorial bar | Top methods + biological demonstration | Top biotechnology technology + translation | Broad multidisciplinary, open access | Top bioinformatics tools |
Submit If
- Your paper has been Under Review for more than 2 weeks and the abstract names the method advance over prior art, not only the new tool name.
- Your benchmarking table compares the method against at least three relevant prior approaches on the same biological or technical task.
- Your code, protocol, data, and example files are stable enough that a reviewer could reproduce the central result without author help.
If your Nature Methods paper is Under Review past 2 weeks, you have cleared the handling editor screen at Nature Portfolio. Use the waiting window to prepare a thorough revision response template.
Nature Methods submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.
Think Twice If
- The methods section works on a toy dataset but the manuscript does not yet show a biological demonstration that changes the question a lab can ask.
- The benchmark figure uses different datasets, thresholds, or sample quality than the prior methods it claims to beat.
- The code repository is private, undocumented, unversioned, or missing example data that would let a reviewer rerun the analysis.
Nature Portfolio handling editors at Nature Methods retain discretion to reject after partial review if reviewer reports surface method-advance or biological-demonstration concerns the desk screen did not catch.
For a pre-upload diagnostic of method advance over prior art and biological demonstration depth, run a Nature Methods pre-submission diagnostic before reviewer reports surface those concerns.
Last verified: Nature Methods author guidance at Nature Portfolio author guidance and Nature Portfolio editorial documentation.
The Nature Methods reviewer experience
Nature Portfolio typically sends manuscripts to two or three reviewers, who are asked about key results, validity, originality and significance, data and methodology, statistics, and conclusions (per the peer-review policy). For a methods paper, we see four things matter most. The table below maps each to actionable preparation.
Reviewer focus area | What reviewers typically evaluate | How to prepare for it |
|---|---|---|
Method advance | Does the method constitute an important advance over prior art (resolution, throughput, cost, accessibility)? | Frame the introduction around the specific limitation of prior methods that this method addresses. The 10-day median triage rewards papers where the advance is immediately apparent. |
Biological demonstration | Does the method enable new biology or substantially improve existing biological inquiries? | Pair method development with at least one biological demonstration that uses the method to address a previously-intractable question. |
Methodological rigor | Are the experimental methods appropriate, benchmarked against existing approaches, and ethically robust? | Include head-to-head benchmarking against state-of-the-art alternatives. Complete reporting for animal work is expected. |
Reproducibility and code | Could another lab reproduce the method with the documentation provided? | Use detailed methods documentation. Nature Portfolio requires a Code availability statement and sharing of code central to the paper with editors and reviewers; release in a DOI-minting repository is best practice. |
What we see in our pre-submission review work on Nature Methods manuscripts
Manusights review data from this journal family shows a specific risk pattern: in practice, we see Nature Methods editors and reviewers specifically look for whether the method changes what a biological or biomedical researcher can do, not only whether it is technically clever. Nature Portfolio's public guidance explains submission mechanics and peer review, but the Under Review window is where authors should prepare for the reviewer split between method specialists and biological users.
This guide tells you what Nature Methods editors look for during the status window. Manusights has reviewed 50+ manuscripts targeting Nature Methods or adjacent methods, biotechnology, computational biology, and Nature Portfolio journals; full Manusights reviews include a 60-day money-back guarantee, and we do not train AI on customer manuscripts.
Benchmarking does not yet compare like with like
Nature Methods reviewers are quick to challenge benchmarks that compare against weak baselines, use easier data for the new method, omit failure cases, or report only the metric where the method wins. We see the strongest packages include same-sample comparisons, ablations, runtime and cost notes, failure-mode examples, and a plain explanation of why the comparison is fair.
If your central figure is a performance table, run a Check whether your Nature Methods benchmark is reviewer-ready ->.
Biological demonstration is too thin for the claim
A Nature Methods paper usually needs to show that the method enables a biological question, not only that it performs on controlled inputs. Reviewers often ask whether the demonstration is a real use case, whether the biological result is plausible, and whether an ordinary lab could reproduce the workflow. During Under Review, prepare a claim map that separates the technical advance, the biological demonstration, and the user-facing consequence.
If those three lines blur together, use a Check if your Nature Methods biological demonstration is strong enough ->.
Reproducibility package is not yet user-grade
Code availability, protocol detail, dependencies, example data, versioning, and documentation are not peripheral at Nature Methods. They are part of the method's credibility. We frequently see reviewer requests for protocols.io-style detail, public code archives, test datasets, environment files, and clearer limits on where the method fails.
If the method would be hard for a reviewer to rerun in one afternoon, run a Check whether your Nature Methods reproducibility package is complete ->.
Nature Methods Pre-Decision Checklist
- Write the exact limitation in prior methods that your method resolves.
- Recheck the benchmark table for same-data, same-threshold, runtime, cost, and failure-case fairness.
- Confirm code, protocol, dependencies, test data, and repository links can survive reviewer inspection.
- Prepare routing language for Nature Biotechnology, Nature Communications, Communications Biology, Nature Protocols, Genome Biology, and Bioinformatics.
Source limitations: Nature Portfolio guidance describes workflow mechanics and editorial policies; the benchmarking, biological-demonstration, and reproducibility guidance here is inferred from those sources plus Manusights manuscript-review patterns, not from private editorial records.
Methodology note
This page was created from Nature Portfolio's public author guidance at Nature Portfolio author guidance, Nature Methods editorial-process documentation and journal metrics (including the 10-day median to first editorial decision), a 9.7-day author-reported first-decision average, Nature Portfolio peer-review guidance, and Manusights pre-submission review experience with Nature Methods-targeted manuscripts.
What to read next
For the Nature Portfolio methods landscape beyond Nature Methods, see Nature Communications (broader scope with open-access), Nature Biotechnology (biotechnology focus), Nature Protocols (protocol focus), and Communications Biology (Nature Portfolio open-access). The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is method-advance-with-biology (Nature Methods), technology-translation (Nature Biotechnology), protocol-document (Nature Protocols), or open-access (Communications Biology).
Reviewers are chosen so that the different technical and conceptual aspects of the work are covered (per the editorial-process page), so expect questions from both method specialists and biological users. Preparing a response template that addresses both perspectives accelerates revision rounds substantially.
For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the Nature Methods method-advance-plus-biological-demonstration bar before submission, our Nature Methods pre-submission diagnostic flags the benchmarking gaps and biological-demonstration weaknesses most likely to surface in reviewer reports.
Frequently asked questions
Your manuscript has cleared Nature Portfolio admin checks and is being evaluated. The handling editor decides whether to reject the paper or send it for peer review, and the journal reports a median of 10 days from submission to first editorial decision.
Nature Methods reports a median of 10 days from submission to first editorial decision and 276 days to acceptance. Authors report 9.7 days to the first editorial decision on average and 56 days to the first revision report; those two are author-reported figures, not journal figures.
Wait at least 8 weeks before inquiring. The journal lists methods@us.nature.com for general editorial inquiries and manuscript status questions.
No. The author-reported 9.7-day first-decision average and 56-day first-revision-report average suggest 5 weeks at Under Review is normal mid-cycle. Reports may already be in editorial synthesis.
Your paper passed the handling editor desk screen and reviewers have been invited. Nature Methods typically sends papers to two to three reviewers, sometimes more if special advice is needed.
Yes. The author-reported 56-day first-revision-report average reflects the typical reviewed-and-revised cycle, and the journal's median of 276 days from submission to acceptance includes all peer review and revision.
Past 10 weeks is the right moment for a polite inquiry. Past 14 weeks suggests a reviewer dropped out and the handling editor needs a replacement. Silence in the first 6 weeks is normal at Nature Portfolio.
Sources
Free guide
Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.
Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.
Final step
Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.
The Nature Methods decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.
Free scan, no card needed.
Target journal Nature Methods
Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.
Re-read the status guidePut the guidance to work
Turn a decision into a clear next step.
Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.
Where to go next
Start here
Same journal, next question
- Nature Methods Review Time: What Authors Can Actually Expect
- Nature Methods Submission Process
- How to Avoid Desk Rejection at Nature Methods
- Is Nature Methods a Good Journal? Fit Verdict
- Is Your Paper Ready for Nature Methods? The Methodological Innovation Test
- Rejected from Nature Methods? The 7 Best Journals to Submit Next