Science Advances 'Under Review': What Each Status Means
If your Science Advances submission shows Under Review, here is what the AAAS deputy editors and associate editors are doing during each stage and when to follow up.
While you wait
Waiting on Science Advances? Get your next move ready.
The Science Advances wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.
Science Advances at a glance
The figures Science Advances publishes about speed, selectivity and cost, each linked to the page we read it on. They describe the journal, not your manuscript's chances.
_Last reviewed: 2026-10-08._
Quick answer: If your Science Advances submission shows "Under Review," elapsed time is the most reliable signal. AAAS reports, for 2025 research content, a median of 8 days from submission to first decision and 58 days to the first post-review decision, with an 8.8% accept rate and 16.4% of submissions externally reviewed (per the AAAS journal metrics page). Read your own clock against that: a rejection in the first weeks is most often an editor decision, while a paper still "Under Review" well past it has usually gone out to referees. If your portal says "Under Evaluation" instead, the Science Advances Under Evaluation guide explains why that label is harder to read. For citation context, use the Science Advances impact factor page.
AAAS does not publish a separate desk-rejection rate, but only 16.4% of 2025 submissions were externally reviewed.
Half of first decisions, whether a rejection or a decision to send the paper for review, arrive within 8 days. For papers that survive the desk and are reviewed, the median first post-review decision comes 58 days after submission. Science Advances is led by the Editor-in-Chief of the Science journals together with the Science Advances editor; verify the current editorial leadership on the journal's editorial-team page before quoting any name in a cover letter.
For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a Science Advances submission readiness check.
Submission portal and editorial contact: Science Advances uses the AAAS Centralized Tracking System at Science family CTS submission portal. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID; the Science Advances editorial office can be reached at ScienceAdvancesEditorial@aaas.org.
Searching for the Science Advances tracking system or CTS login? It is the same Centralized Tracking System that Science itself uses. Whatever label it shows, count the weeks since submission and place your paper in the pipeline table below; keep a note of when the status last changed, so that any inquiry can give the editors the manuscript ID and that date in one line.
The Science Advances information for authors and the Science Advances information for reviewers cover the submission steps and the peer-review process, but not the portal's status names.
How AAAS handles a Science Advances submission
Science Advances operates the AAAS deputy editor + associate editor model. Science Advances is led by the Editor-in-Chief of the Science journals together with the Science Advances editor, who lead a growing team of deputy and associate editors who can evaluate submissions over a very broad range of disciplines.
Verify the current editorial leadership on the journal's editorial-team page before quoting any name in a cover letter. A deputy editor might reject a paper without review or handle the review personally, or send it to an associate editor with more specialized expertise (per a 2022 editorial by a Science Advances senior deputy editor).
In the Physical and Materials Sciences group, a 2022 editorial by a Science Advances senior deputy editor says deputy editors commonly handle 50 to 100 papers per month; deputy and associate editors are active researchers who do not do the job full time. The senior editor team coordinates across the very broad range of disciplines.
Science Advances editorial culture is decisive: AAAS reports that only 16.4% of 2025 submissions were externally reviewed. Papers that pass the Science Advances desk screen have cleared the steepest filter in AAAS open-access publishing.
Science Advances's review pipeline
Stage (generic, not portal labels) | What is happening | AAAS-reported timing |
|---|---|---|
Submitted | Files received in the AAAS Centralized Tracking System | Not published by AAAS |
Editor evaluation | A deputy or associate editor evaluates broad significance and scientific validity | Median 8 days to first decision (to send for review or reject) |
Under review | At least two reviewers evaluate the paper; reviewers are anonymous to authors | Reviewers are asked to return evaluations within three weeks; median 58 days to first post-review decision |
Decision | Accept, revise or reject | Median 174 days from submission to acceptance |
The deputy editor + associate editor desk screen (most submissions are not externally reviewed)
Before the paper reaches external reviewers, a Science Advances deputy editor or associate editor evaluates whether the broad-significance and scientific validity warrant Science Advances's editorial slots. Most submissions are rejected at this stage: AAAS reports a 16.4% external review rate for 2025.
A desk rejection most often means the editor concluded that the work would fit better at a sister AAAS journal (Science flagship for top-tier broad-significance, Science Translational Medicine for clinical-translation, Science Signaling for cell-signaling) or that the Science Advances broad-significance bar is not met.
What does the submission package need?
A complete package includes the cover letter, the manuscript (a .docx file, preferred, or LaTeX) and a combined PDF with figures, tables and Supplementary Material, any auxiliary files, five suggested reviewers, and the author, ethics, competing-interest and data-availability information the submission form asks for. The Science journals require ARRIVE for animal research and ask for a CONSORT checklist for randomized trials, and clinical trials should generally be registered.
What does the editor evaluate first?
A handling deputy editor or associate editor evaluates broad significance and scientific validity, and routes the paper within the journal's five editorial sections: social and interdisciplinary sciences, neuroscience, earth, environmental, ecological and space sciences, physical and materials sciences, and biomedicine and life sciences.
Does editor consultation add time?
A 2022 editorial by a Science Advances senior deputy editor says a deputy editor will often send a paper to one or more associate editors with better specialized expertise. AAAS does not publish how much time consultation adds.
When are Science Advances reviewers recruited?
Editors invite reviewers who first see only the title and abstract and must declare that they will keep the manuscript confidential and have no conflicts of interest. All papers published in Science Advances must have a minimum of two reviewers. AAAS does not publish how long recruitment takes.
What happens during active peer review?
Reviewers are asked to return their evaluations within three weeks, although assigning editors may change that; AAAS reports a median of 58 days from submission to the first post-review decision. Reviewers are asked to give objective assessments of the research, and they are anonymous to authors.
What happens after reviews come back?
After reports return, editors decide on revision or rejection; Science Advances editors are responsible for all final decisions to reject or accept a manuscript. If your paper has been in the system for 4 or more weeks without a decision, it is more likely to be in external review than in desk screening, since the median first decision is 8 days.
When to worry
- Rejection within 1 to 14 days: Administrative issue or fast-track desk rejection.
- Rejection within 14 to 28 days: Likely a deputy or associate editor desk rejection.
- Still Under Review after 4 weeks: Likely past the desk screen and in external review, since the median first decision is 8 days.
- Still Under Review after 12 weeks: Reviewer-recruitment or reviewer-report delay. A polite inquiry via the AAAS Centralized Tracking System is appropriate.
- A status change after the reviews arrive: AAAS does not document portal status names or how long a decision takes after reports are in.
"My paper has been Under Review for 5 weeks. Is that bad?"
This is the most common anxiety we hear from Science Advances authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: no, 5 weeks at Under Review is earlier than the 58-day median first post-review decision that AAAS reports. Reviewers are asked to return evaluations within three weeks, so reports may already be in with the editor, or still pending.
Reviewer-driven delays can come from recruitment timing or late reviews. If the portal still says Under Review at the 8-week mark, you are near the 58-day median, and one explanation is a late reviewer; AAAS does not publish how often extensions are granted.
An email to the editorial office during the 5-to-8-week window is unlikely to help, since the paper is still inside the typical range; wait until you are well past the median. Science Advances deputy editors and associate editors are active researchers working around their own laboratories.
What to do while waiting
- Do not email the editorial office during the first 6 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
- Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at Science Advances. AAAS has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
- Prepare a point-by-point response template for likely reviewer concerns: broad-significance, scientific validity, methodology rigor, reproducibility.
- If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
- Read recent Science Advances papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.
What we see in Science Advances status-anxiety reviews
In our review of Science Advances-targeted manuscripts, the authors most likely to misread the portal are the ones who treat "Under Review" as proof that external reviewers are already writing reports. The safer interpretation is stage-based: before week 4, assume the manuscript may still be with an AAAS editor; after week 4 with no desk rejection, prepare as if reviewer comments could arrive next.
The practical value is emotional and strategic. You avoid sending a premature inquiry, and you can use the waiting period to tighten the response plan around broad significance, data availability, and reproducibility rather than refreshing the portal.
Readiness check
While you wait on Science Advances, scan your next manuscript.
The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.
If Science Advances rejects: sister-journal cascade with reasoning
If your Science Advances paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the reviewers and deputy editor cited:
Science (the AAAS flagship) is the natural AAAS top-tier cascade for top-tier broad-significance work. Science uses the AAAS Centralized Tracking System at Science family CTS submission portal; editorial contact science_editors@aaas.org.
Science Translational Medicine is the AAAS clinical-translation cascade.
Science Signaling is the AAAS cell-signaling cascade.
Science Immunology is the AAAS immunology cascade.
Science Robotics is the AAAS robotics cascade.
Nature Communications is the external Springer Nature broader-scope cascade. The Nature Communications Manuscript Tracking System at mts-ncomms.nature.com handles submission; ncomms@nature.com handles publisher-level inquiries.
PNAS is the external NAS broader-scope cascade.
eLife is a cascade option for life-sciences work under the Reviewed Preprint model.
How Science Advances compares to nearby alternatives
Feature | Science Advances | Science | Nature Communications | PNAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Desk-rejection rate | ~84 percent not externally reviewed (AAAS, 2025) | ~85 percent not externally reviewed (AAAS, 2025) | 72.5% rejected outright (March 2015 to February 2017) | More than 50 percent |
Desk-decision speed | 8-day median first decision (AAAS, 2025) | 8-day median first decision (AAAS, 2025) | 7 to 21 days | 5 to 7 days |
Total review time (post-screen) | 58-day median to first post-review decision (AAAS, 2025) | 64-day median to first post-review decision; 184-day median to acceptance (AAAS, 2025) | 2 to 4 months | 2.0-month Direct Submission median |
Reviewer count | Minimum of 2 reviewers for published papers | At least 2 outside referees for in-depth review + BoRE consultation | 2 to 3 | 2 independent experts |
Peer-review model | Anonymous reviewers (identities not disclosed to authors) | Confidential single-blind + BoRE | Transparent (mandatory if accepted) | NAS Editorial Board + member editor |
Editorial bar | AAAS open-access broad-significance | Top-tier broad-significance | Broad-significance, broader than Nature | Multidisciplinary broad-significance |
Submit If
- Your abstract and first figure communicate broad AAAS significance, not just a strong result for one specialty.
- Your Methods, data, and code availability let reviewers test scientific validity without asking for missing core evidence.
- Your cover letter explains why Science Advances, rather than Science, PNAS, Nature Communications, or a specialty journal, is the right venue.
Science Advances submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.
Think Twice If
- The introduction needs more than two paragraphs before the broad multidisciplinary significance becomes clear.
- The main figures rely on one model system, one dataset, or one analysis pipeline without an orthogonal validation figure.
- The data or code availability statement does not let an AAAS reviewer reproduce the central analysis behind the claims.
For a pre-upload diagnostic of broad-significance framing and scientific validity, run a Science Advances pre-submission diagnostic before reviewer reports surface those concerns.
Last verified: Science Advances information for authors at AAAS author instructions and AAAS editorial documentation.
What checklist should you run while waiting?
- [ ] Abstract and first figure make the broad AAAS significance explicit before specialty details.
- [ ] Methods, data, and code availability support every central result, figure, and statistical claim.
- [ ] Cover letter explains why Science Advances is the right route compared with Science, PNAS, Nature Communications, or a specialty journal.
- [ ] Response outline anticipates broad-significance, reproducibility, and venue-fit reviewer questions.
The Science Advances reviewer experience
AAAS's reviewer page asks for objective evaluations of the research. The table below is Manusights' reading of what reviewers tend to weigh, mapped to actionable preparation.
Reviewer focus area | What reviewers are likely to weigh | How to prepare for it |
|---|---|---|
Broad-significance | Does the work matter for the broad Science Advances multidisciplinary readership? | Frame the introduction around the broad-significance principle the findings illuminate. The high share of submissions that are not externally reviewed selects for papers with clear broad-significance. |
Scientific validity | Are the methods scientifically valid and rigorously implemented? | Include detailed methods documentation. Scientific validity is a primary editorial criterion. |
Reproducibility | Could another team reproduce the central experiments with the methods, data, and code as written? | Use detailed methods documentation. AAAS requires data-availability statements. Deposit raw data and code in public repositories. |
Reviewer match | A minimum of two reviewers for published papers, drawn from the broad academic pool | Reviewers are anonymous to authors and selected by the editors from the broad academic pool covering the very broad range of disciplines. |
What we see in our pre-submission review work at Science Advances
Across Science Advances-targeted manuscripts, three named patterns generate the most consistent reviewer concerns and the most common reasons papers miss the editorial bar or fail the desk screen. Science Advances is not a fallback for work that is merely "good but not Science." The paper still has to read as broad, rigorous, and useful across a wide AAAS readership.
The problems we see most often are broad-significance claims that arrive too late, methods packages that cannot support multidisciplinary scrutiny, and cascade logic that is not explicit enough for a deputy editor to route the paper confidently.
Narrow-significance framing flagged at deputy editor + associate editor desk screen. When the introduction frames the work too narrowly within one subspecialty without broad significance for the Science Advances multidisciplinary readership, deputy editor desk rejection is common. In Science Advances-targeted manuscripts, we often see a strong technical result buried under a subfield-first introduction. The stronger version starts with the scientific principle, societal or cross-disciplinary problem, or mechanism class the paper changes, then uses the specialty result as evidence.
Check whether your Science Advances framing is broad enough →
Reproducibility gaps surface as reviewer concerns. When data and code are not deposited in public repositories or methods documentation is thin, Science Advances reviewers consistently flag reproducibility concerns. The strongest manuscripts deposit data and code alongside submission and use the figure legends to make the underlying evidence traceable. For computational, imaging, high-throughput, or clinical manuscripts, reviewers need to see versioned code, raw or minimally processed data, sample-size logic, and the exact statistical model behind each central figure.
Check if your Science Advances data and code package will survive review →
AAAS family cascade offers from deputy editor. When the deputy editor concludes the work is rigorous but the broad-significance bar of Science Advances is exceeded or misaligned, transfer offers to Science flagship or another AAAS journal can happen. We also see the reverse: papers that should have gone to a more specialist venue are held up because the cover letter does not explain why the Science Advances readership needs the work.
The strongest submissions make the cascade logic explicit in the cover letter and avoid forcing the editor to infer venue fit.
Check your Science Advances venue-fit logic before submission →
This guide tells you what Science Advances editors look for while the manuscript is being routed or reviewed. The review tells you whether your paper passes that check before the decision arrives. We have reviewed manuscripts targeting Science Advances and peer general-science venues; the named patterns above are the same ones deputy editors, associate editors, and outside reviewers flag during first review. 60 (as of October 2026)-day money-back guarantee. Your manuscript is not used for model training, and access is limited to the review workflow.
Methodology note
This page was created from AAAS's public Science Advances information for authors at AAAS author instructions, AAAS editorial documentation (the journal-metrics medians for 2025, the information for reviewers page, and the leadership under the Science journals Editor-in-Chief together with the Science Advances editor), and Manusights pre-submission review experience with Science Advances-targeted manuscripts.
Source limitation: AAAS public materials explain the Science Advances editorial model, but they do not expose reviewer invitations, editor consultation notes, or why a manuscript remains visible in one portal state. Official guidance covers the visible workflow; the added Manusights layer comes from our pre-submission review work on status-anxiety manuscripts across Science Advances and adjacent general-science venues, where the strongest predictor of author confusion was whether the abstract, data/code package, and venue-fit logic made the broad-significance case clear enough for AAAS review.
What to read next
For the AAAS open-access landscape beyond Science Advances, see Science (AAAS flagship), Science Translational Medicine (clinical-translation), Science Signaling (cell-signaling), Science Immunology (immunology), Science Robotics (robotics), and external open-access multidisciplinary alternatives (Nature Communications, PNAS, eLife).
The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is AAAS open-access broad-significance (Science Advances), top-tier AAAS broad-significance (Science), AAAS clinical-translation (Science Translational Medicine), AAAS cell-signaling (Science Signaling), AAAS immunology (Science Immunology), AAAS robotics (Science Robotics), Nature Portfolio broader scope (Nature Communications), NAS broad-significance (PNAS), or Reviewed Preprint (eLife).
Reviewers at Science Advances come from across the very broad range of disciplines covered, with a minimum of two reviewers for any published paper. Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any reviewer sees them, and preparing a response template that addresses both broad-significance and scientific validity perspectives accelerates revision rounds substantially.
For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the Science Advances broad-significance-plus-scientific-validity bar before submission, our Science Advances pre-submission diagnostic flags the broad-significance framing and reproducibility weaknesses most likely to surface in reviewer reports.
How long has your manuscript been at Science Advances?
Pick its current status and the date you submitted. We compare the wait with the median Science Advances publishes. Your entry stays in this browser, so come back any time to see the updated count.
Frequently asked questions
AAAS's public pages do not define the status names shown in the Science Advances submission portal, so any reading of 'Under Review' is an author-reported interpretation. It generally means the manuscript is in editorial handling or external review and no decision has been sent. Science Advances is led by the Editor-in-Chief of the Science journals together with the Science Advances editor, who lead a growing team of deputy and associate editors who can evaluate submissions over a very broad range of disciplines. Verify the current editorial leadership on the journal's editorial-team page before quoting any name in a cover letter.
AAAS's journal-metrics page reports, for 2025 research content, a median of 8 days from submission to first decision (to send for review or to reject) and a median of 58 days to the first post-review decision. Only 16.4% of 2025 submissions were externally reviewed.
Wait until the paper is well past the 58-day median first post-review decision, for example about 10 weeks, before inquiring. Contact the Science Advances editorial office (ScienceAdvancesEditorial@aaas.org) with your manuscript ID.
No. Five weeks is earlier than the 58-day (about 8-week) median first post-review decision that AAAS reports, so it is not unusual. Reviewers are asked to return evaluations within three weeks, although the assigning editor can adjust that.
All papers published in Science Advances must have a minimum of two reviewers, and reviewers are asked to return their evaluations within three weeks, although assigning editors may change that. Editors share reviews with the authors, and possibly with other reviewers and editorial board members.
Yes. The median time to the first post-review decision is 58 days, so about half of reviewed papers take longer, and the median time to acceptance is 174 days.
There is no official threshold. A polite inquiry is reasonable once the paper is well past the 58-day median first post-review decision, for example after about 12 weeks. Silence in the first several weeks is normal.
Sources
Free guide
Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.
Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.
Final step
Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.
The Science Advances decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.
Free scan, no card needed.
Target journal Science Advances
Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.
Re-read the status guidePut the guidance to work
Turn a decision into a clear next step.
Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.
Where to go next
Start here
Same journal, next question
- Science Advances Review Time: What Authors Can Actually Expect
- Science Advances Under Evaluation: What the Status Usually Means
- Science Advances Submission Process (2026): How To Submit And What Happens Next
- How to Avoid Desk Rejection at Science Advances
- Is Science Advances a Good Journal? A Practical Fit Check for Authors
- Science Advances 'With Editor': The Deputy-Editor Desk-Screen Stage Explained