Skip to main content

American Economic Review 'Under Review': What Each Status Means

If your American Economic Review submission shows Under Review, here is what the AEA coeditor is doing during each stage and when to follow up.

Editorial processThe Manusights editorial team researches and maintains these guides using source review, field-specific analysis, and our documented editorial process.How we work

While you wait

Waiting on a decision? Get your next move ready.

The wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.What the status means

Quick answer: If an American Economic Review manuscript shows Under Review, it is in active coeditor handling or external review; the label does not prove that all referees are assigned or that the outcome is favorable. Interpret it using the status history, the AER process, and any promised date. An early coeditor screen and a full referee cycle are different queues, so one universal countdown is misleading.

Who are the AER editors, and who is reading your paper? The AEA publishes the current editor and coeditor roster on the AER pages of its own site; we do not reproduce names here because the board rotates. For a paper under review, the structure matters more than the names: one coeditor takes your manuscript at intake and handles it to the final decision, and before a first revise-and-resubmit that coeditor asks a second coeditor for input.

Evidence basis: We checked current AER editorial-process sources and the cited dated metrics on 2026-08-13, separating AEA facts from Manusights status interpretation and manuscript-specific uncertainty.

AER status decision map

Decision layer
Use this page to decide
Status meaning
Whether the paper may be in coeditor handling or external review
Timing
Whether elapsed time and any promised date support concern
Action
Whether to wait, prepare for reports, or send a concise inquiry

Use this page: Combine the prior status, elapsed time, and correspondence before selecting the matching threshold below, then preserve that evidence for any inquiry.

Before acting: In our status-review work, we trace AER interpretation failures such as assuming referee assignment, forecasting acceptance, or contacting the office without the manuscript history.

Next step: Use the status map and choose the least disruptive action supported by direct evidence.

The American Economic Review has a 2025 Journal Impact Factor of 9.5 in the 2026 JCR release, and has an acceptance rate of about 6.5 percent in steady state, and in the 2025 reporting year it summarily rejected about 39 percent of initial submissions (per the AER's Report of the Editor); the AER editorial policy says a manuscript may be returned without review based on several considerations, including expected probability of meeting the standards of the AER, breadth of topic, and interest to the AER audience (per AER editorial policy).

Use this page if your question is American Economic Review under review: it explains coeditor handling and what to prepare.

For a second opinion before referees see your manuscript, run a American Economic Review submission readiness check.

Submission portal and editorial contact: American Economic Review uses ScholarOne Manuscripts at ScholarOne submission portal. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID; the AER contact page lists the editorial office's phone number and email address. The American Economic Review journal hub, AER editorial policy, and AER editorial process documentation provide the source baseline for this status guide.

American Economic Review editorial culture

American Economic Review coeditors screen for a contribution that can matter across economics, not only technical correctness inside one field. During external review, referees test identification, theory, measurement, robustness, and whether the result changes an economic question worth the journal's broad audience. A long unchanged label may therefore reflect reviewer recruitment, report completion, or coeditor synthesis. The safest interpretation is procedural: watch elapsed time and correspondence, but do not infer quality from the label alone. One AER habit changes how to read a long wait: the coeditor assigned at intake stays your handling editor to the end, and before a first revise-and-resubmit that coeditor asks a second coeditor for input. A paper heading toward an R&R can therefore sit still for an extra stretch after the last report arrives, which reads as silence but is a second reader weighing the case.

If you searched for the AER editors or editorial board to work out who holds your paper, the structure matters more than the names. The editor assigns each new submission to one coeditor, and that coeditor acts as the handling editor for the whole file: desk screen, referee choice, and the decision letter, with a second coeditor consulted before a first revise-and-resubmit. Coeditors are working academic economists, so a slow week often means teaching or their own research, not a verdict. Rosters rotate, so take current names from the AEA's own American Economic Review pages rather than a third-party list; we do not reproduce them here.

How AEA handles an American Economic Review submission

In our pre-submission review work on American Economic Review submissions, what we see during the review process is a long, demanding evaluation focused on whether a paper makes a major, general contribution to economics: the revisions that succeed sharpen that contribution and close identification or theoretical gaps rather than add applications. Most papers that stall at the AER do so at the editorial desk, before review, on whether the contribution is important and general enough. While under review, expect a slow process and answer the core significance and rigor concerns directly, since that, not presentation, is what an AER outcome turns on.

American Economic Review operates the AEA editor + coeditor model. When a manuscript is received, the editor assigns it to a coeditor to oversee the review process and make a publication decision.

The handling coeditor reads the entire paper and evaluates economics significance, methodological rigor, breadth of topic for AER audience, and AER subfield routing across labor economics, macroeconomics, microeconomic theory, applied microeconomics, behavioral economics, and econometrics.

AER coeditors are working academic economists fitting AER editorial work around their own research, and the Report of the Editor counts 2,114 new submissions in the 2025 reporting year. The Editor (the AEA's title for the lead role; listed on the journal's editorial-team page, so verify before quoting a name) assigns each new submission to a coeditor or handles it personally.

AER editorial culture is decisive: about 40 percent of submissions are summarily rejected (39 percent in the 2025 reporting year). Papers that pass the AER coeditor desk screen have cleared the first filter, not the last: 54 percent of 2025 decisions on initial submissions were rejections with referee reports.

What is American Economic Review's review pipeline?

Status
What is happening
Typical duration
Submitted
AER ScholarOne administrative processing
The AER publishes no figure
With Coeditor
Coeditor evaluating economics significance + breadth + AER audience interest
Summary rejections typically within a week or two, virtually always within a month (Report of the Editor, 2025)
Second-Coeditor Consultation
Before a first R&R, coeditor consults a second coeditor
The AER publishes no figure; may not be visible to the author
Under Review
Referees invited under single-blind review (about three reports on average)
Mean decision time just under three months for rejections with reports and a bit over four months for invitations to revise (Report of the Editor, 2025)
Required Reviews Complete
Coeditor synthesizing referee reports
The AER publishes no figure
Decision Pending
Coeditor + second coeditor finalizing recommendation
The AER publishes no figure
Decision Sent
Reject or R&R at first decision (no first-submission paper was conditionally accepted in 2025)
Check email

What happens at the coeditor desk screen?

Before the paper reaches external referees, an AER coeditor evaluates whether the economics significance and breadth warrant AER's editorial slots. About 39 percent of initial submissions were summarily rejected at this stage in the 2025 reporting year (Report of the Editor). The AER editorial policy says the decision to return a manuscript without review is based on several considerations, including expected probability of meeting the standards of the AER, breadth of topic, and interest to the AER audience.

Papers that were reviewed at AER can use the AEA transfer option to an AEJ journal (AEJ: Applied Economics, AEJ: Macroeconomics, AEJ: Microeconomics, AEJ: Economic Policy); the AEA's transfer option FAQ describes how it works.

What happens during AER intake processing?

The submission has to be complete before review. The AER guidelines ask for a PDF manuscript with title, byline, and affiliations on the first page and an abstract of 100 or fewer words; a separate Disclosure Statement PDF from each (co)author covering financial support, conflicts of interest, and IRB approval for human-subjects data (submissions without these statements are considered incomplete and will not be reviewed); the AEA RCT registration number for field experiments; and a brief description of any AI use in preparing the manuscript. A cover letter and AEA template formatting are optional. Data and code are due before acceptance and are reviewed by the AEA data editor after conditional acceptance, though data access limitations should be noted at submission.

What happens at the coeditor screen?

The handling coeditor reads the paper and evaluates economics significance, methodological rigor, breadth of topic for AER audience, and AER subfield routing. The desk screen is fast: the Report of the Editor says summary rejections typically come within a week or two and virtually always within a month.

Second-coeditor consultation (before a first R&R decision)

Before giving a first revise-and-resubmit decision, the coeditor will consult a second coeditor of their choosing for input. This second-coeditor consultation is AER's distinctive feature: R&R decisions come after the handling coeditor has consulted a second coeditor for input. The AER does not publish how long the consultation takes, and it may not be visible to the author in the portal.

What happens during referee recruitment?

AER used 2.9 referee reports on average for rejections with reports in the 2025 reporting year, and 3.4 for invitations to revise. The AER does not publish a recruitment time; it can run long because referees with topic-matched economics subfield expertise are scarce, and under the single-blind model the referee knows the author's identity.

What happens during active peer review?

Once referees agree to review, the Report of the Editor shows a mean decision time just under three months for rejections with reports and a bit over four months for invitations to revise (2025 reporting year). The AER reviewer guidelines ask for a clear and thoughtful explanation of why the paper's execution and contribution to the literature do or do not make it suitable for publication in the AER, and say that for requested revisions it is helpful to separate comments into essential and optional changes. Expect detailed referee comments.

What happens after the reports return?

After reports return, the coeditor synthesizes them and (for R&R decisions) consults a second coeditor of their choosing. Total submission-to-acceptance averaged 130 weeks for articles published in 2025, of which 38 weeks were in peer review and 13 in data review, and conditional acceptances in 2025 came after 2.0 revisions on average (Report of the Editor). Multiple revision rounds are typical.

When to worry

  • Rejection within 1 to 14 days: Usually a summary rejection, which the Report of the Editor says typically comes within a week or two.
  • Rejection within 14 to 28 days: Still most likely a summary rejection if no referee reports come with it; the report says virtually all come within a month.
  • Still Under Review after 4 weeks: Strong signal. Paper passed the AER coeditor desk screen.
  • Still Under Review after 16 weeks: Referee-recruitment or referee-report delay. A polite inquiry is appropriate; about 81 percent of papers sent for review had a first decision within four months (2025 submission year, Report of the Editor).
  • Status changes to "Decision Pending": Reports are in; the AER publishes no figure for this step, and a second-coeditor consultation comes before a first revise-and-resubmit.

"My paper has been Under Review for 8 weeks. Is that bad?"

This is the most common anxiety we hear from AER authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: no, eight weeks is early: the Report of the Editor shows about 26 percent of papers sent for review had a first decision within two months and 62 percent within three months (2025 submission year). Reports may still be arriving with the coeditor preparing for editorial synthesis and (for R&R decisions) second-coeditor consultation.

Delays at this stage usually mean referee reports are still outstanding. If the portal still says Under Review at the 16-week mark, you are in the slower tail: about 81 percent of papers sent for review had a first decision within four months (2025 submission year, Report of the Editor).

What you should NOT do during the 8-to-16-week window is email the editorial office. AER coeditors are working academic economists handling many papers a year around their own research; an inquiry at 8 weeks adds friction without accelerating the timeline.

What to do while waiting

  • Do not email the editorial office during the first 8 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
  • Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at AER. AEA has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
  • Prepare a comprehensive point-by-point response template for likely referee concerns: economics significance, methodological rigor (identification strategy for causal-inference papers, structural-model robustness for theory papers), replication-data adequacy, contribution clarity.
  • If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
  • Read recent AER papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.

Readiness check

While you wait, scan your next manuscript.

The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.Open status guide

If American Economic Review rejects: sister-journal cascade with reasoning

Our full guide to where to submit after an AER rejection ranks the AEJ transfer options against QJE, JPE and ReStud; the short version follows.

If your AER paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the referees and coeditor cited:

AER: Insights is the natural AEA short-format cascade for high-impact short papers.

AEJ: Applied Economics is the AEA cascade for applied microeconomics.

AEJ: Macroeconomics is the AEA cascade for macroeconomics.

AEJ: Microeconomics is the AEA cascade for microeconomic theory.

AEJ: Economic Policy is the AEA cascade for economic policy.

Econometrica is the external Econometric Society cascade for top-tier economics theory and econometrics.

Quarterly Journal of Economics (QJE) is the external Harvard/Oxford cascade for top-tier general economics.

Journal of Political Economy (JPE) is the external University of Chicago cascade for top-tier general economics.

How American Economic Review compares to nearby alternatives

Feature
American Economic Review
Econometrica
AER: Insights
Desk-rejection rate
About 39 percent (Report of the Editor, 2025)
36.5% of papers summarily rejected (2024/25 reporting year)
Not published
Not published
Desk-decision speed
Typically within a week or two (Report of the Editor, 2025)
<2 weeks
90-day target for high-quality feedback
2 to 4 weeks
Total review time (post-screen)
Mean just under 3 months for rejections with reports, a bit over 4 for invitations to revise (Report of the Editor, 2025)
3 to 6 month first decision
65-day Department Editor decision average
2 to 4 months
Reviewer count
About 3 on average (single-blind)
2 to 3 (single-blind, can include AEs)
2 to 3 (double-anonymous)
2 to 3
Peer-review model
Single-blind + coeditor + second-coeditor consultation
Editor + coeditor + AE + referees
Double-anonymous + department editor structure
Single-blind + short-format
Editorial bar
Top economics + breadth + AER audience interest
Top economic theory + econometrics + AE judgment
Top business/operations + double-anonymous discipline
Top short-format economics

AER Status Inquiry Checklist

  • [ ] The manuscript ID, current ScholarOne status, and date the status first changed to Under Review.
  • [ ] Whether the introduction states the broad economics question in the first three pages.
  • [ ] Whether the main tables carry the identification logic instead of sending the reader to the appendix for the core proof.
  • [ ] Whether the replication package, disclosure statements, and data-legality notes are ready for a future R&R or conditional acceptance.

The American Economic Review referee experience

The AER reviewer guidelines ask referees for a clear and thoughtful explanation of why the paper's execution and contribution to the literature do or do not make it suitable for publication in the AER. The table below maps four areas that follow from that to actionable preparation.

Reviewer focus area
What referees typically weigh
How to prepare for it
Economics significance
Does the work advance economics understanding beyond incremental contribution?
Frame the introduction around the economics significance the findings illuminate. The roughly 40 percent summary-rejection rate selects for papers with clear economics significance.
Methodological rigor (identification or structural)
Are the identification strategy (causal-inference) or structural-model assumptions (theory) appropriate, properly justified, and rigorously implemented?
Include detailed methodology documentation. Identification strategy or structural-model assumptions are the primary methodological criteria.
Breadth and AER audience interest
Does the work appeal to the broad AER audience beyond a narrow subfield?
Frame the broad interest in the introduction. Breadth-of-topic issues are explicit desk-rejection criteria.
Replication-data adequacy
Are replication data and code ready to be made available in a trusted repository before acceptance?
Deposit replication data and code. The AEA Data and Code Availability Policy applies before acceptance, and the AEA data editor checks compliance after conditional acceptance.

What we see in our pre-submission review work at AER

Across AER-targeted manuscripts, and in our review of 50+ nearby economics manuscripts, Manusights review data shows three named patterns generate the most consistent referee concerns and the most common reasons papers miss the AER editorial bar or fail the coeditor desk screen. The failure point is usually visible before the econometrics are challenged. Coeditors are deciding whether the abstract, introduction, identification strategy, tables, and replication package support a broad economics contribution that belongs in the American Economic Review rather than a field journal or an AEJ title.

Narrow-subfield framing flagged at AER coeditor desk screen. When the introduction frames the work too narrowly within one economics subfield without broad AER audience interest, coeditor desk rejection is common. The strongest AER manuscripts use the first three pages to explain the general economic question, why the setting identifies it unusually well, and how the result changes what economists outside the subfield should believe.

If the title and abstract only promise a setting-specific estimate, the paper often looks more like an AEJ or field-journal submission.

Check whether your AER broad-interest claim is visible →

Excessive reliance on online appendices flagged at AER desk screen. When the main paper relies too heavily on online appendices for core identification details, structural assumptions, robustness checks, or data construction, the coeditor has to judge the paper from an incomplete main manuscript. In our reviews, the strongest AER revisions move the central identification logic, key robustness table, and data-quality explanation into the main text. The appendix should support the paper, not contain the reason the estimate is credible.

Check if your AER identification package is reviewer-ready →

AEJ family cascade through the AEA transfer option. When the coeditor concludes the work is rigorous but the broad AER audience bar is not met, authors commonly consider the AEA transfer option to AEJ: Applied Economics, AEJ: Macroeconomics, AEJ: Microeconomics, or AEJ: Economic Policy, or a fresh submission to AER: Insights.

The right next journal is usually signaled by the manuscript components themselves: a compact general result may fit AER: Insights, a policy estimate may fit AEJ: Economic Policy, and a narrower applied-micro contribution may fit AEJ: Applied Economics. The pre-submission fix is to align the abstract, introduction, tables, data appendix, and replication statement with the broad AER claim before waiting through Under Review.

Check your AER cascade response plan →

This guide tells you what AER editors look for while the manuscript is being routed or reviewed. The review tells you whether your paper passes that breadth-and-identification check before the decision arrives. Manusights has reviewed 50+ manuscripts targeting AER and nearby economics venues, offers a 60-day money-back guarantee for eligible review orders, and we do not train AI on private author manuscripts.

Source limitation: this guidance combines official guidance, public status/timing signals, and anonymized Manusights pre-submission review patterns; it does not use private AEA editorial records. Compared with official guidance, the useful reader-facing value is translating the status into broad-interest, identification, and replication-package checks authors can act on while waiting.

Methodology note

This page was created from AEA's public AER editorial policy at Aeaweb editorial team page, AER editorial process documentation (about 40 percent summary rejections per the Report of the Editor for the 2025 reporting year, coeditor model with single-blind review, second-coeditor consultation before R&R, single-blind peer review with author identity revealed to referee but referee anonymous to author, Editor Erzo F.P. Luttmer of Dartmouth College per the AER editors page, data and code made available in a trusted repository before acceptance), and Manusights pre-submission review experience with AER-targeted manuscripts.

For the AEA economics landscape beyond AER, see AER: Insights (short-format), AEJ: Applied Economics (applied micro), AEJ: Macroeconomics, AEJ: Microeconomics, AEJ: Economic Policy, and external top-tier economics alternatives (Econometrica, QJE, JPE, Review of Economic Studies).

The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is top general economics (AER), top short-format (AER: Insights), applied micro (AEJ: Applied Economics), macro (AEJ: Macroeconomics), micro theory (AEJ: Microeconomics), policy (AEJ: Economic Policy), top economic theory/econometrics (Econometrica), top general economics (QJE, JPE), or top general economics with European editorial focus (Review of Economic Studies). If none of those fits, the full journal directory covers fields beyond economics.

For stronger cluster routing, compare this page with the American Economic Review submission guide, Econometrica under review, and Management Science under review before deciding whether the status meaning or the venue fit is the real question.

Referees at AER are economics subfield experts, with about three reports on average per reviewed paper, under the AEA single-blind model. Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any referee sees them, and preparing a response template that addresses breadth-of-topic and AER audience interest alongside methodological rigor accelerates revision rounds substantially.

For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the AER economics-significance-plus-breadth bar before submission, our American Economic Review pre-submission diagnostic flags the breadth and online-appendices weaknesses most likely to surface in the coeditor desk screen.

Submit If

If your AER paper is Under Review past 4 weeks, you have cleared the coeditor desk screen. Use the waiting window to prepare a comprehensive revision response template (multiple R&R rounds are typical in economics).

American Economic Review submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.

Think Twice If

AER coeditors retain discretion to reject after partial review if referee reports surface methodological or economics-significance concerns the desk screen did not catch. The roughly 6.5 percent overall acceptance rate in the Report of the Editor means most post-desk-screen papers still receive a reject or R&R decision (R&R with multiple rounds is the typical path to acceptance at AER).

  • Your first three pages define a narrow setting but do not tell economists outside the subfield what belief should change.
  • Your main tables rely on appendix-only identification details, robustness checks, sample construction, or structural assumptions.
  • Your replication package is incomplete, with sample construction, data provenance, code order, random seed handling, or disclosure statements still unresolved.

For a pre-upload diagnostic of economics significance framing and replication-data adequacy, run a American Economic Review pre-submission diagnostic before referee reports surface those concerns.

Last verified: AER editorial policy at Aeaweb editorial team page and AER editorial process documentation.

Reporting-checklist check: when the study design triggers one, attach the relevant primary checklist before resubmission: CONSORT for randomized trials, STROBE for observational studies, PRISMA for systematic reviews, ARRIVE for animal studies, and STARD for diagnostic-accuracy work. If none applies, make that clear in the submission notes instead of forcing a checklist.

Evidence basis

AEA and AER sources below were accessed 2026-08-13; official process and policy facts are distinct from Manusights interpretation of an individual status history. Direct editor correspondence controls for a specific manuscript.

Frequently asked questions

Your manuscript has cleared AER ScholarOne admin checks and is being evaluated. When a manuscript is received, the editor assigns it to a coeditor to oversee the review process and make a publication decision, and papers are handled by the designated coeditor throughout the decision process. Before giving a first revise-and-resubmit decision, the coeditor will consult a second coeditor of their choosing for input. All manuscripts submitted to the American Economic Review undergo single-blind peer review.

AER operates two tracks. According to the AER's Report of the Editor for the 2025 reporting year, summary rejections (about 39 percent of decisions on initial submissions) typically come within a week or two and virtually always within a month, while papers sent to referees averaged 2.9 reports on rejections and had a mean decision time just under three months for rejections with reports and a bit over four months for invitations to revise. The current Editor-in-Chief is listed on the journal's editorial-team page; verify the incumbent before quoting any name.

Wait at least 8 weeks before inquiring. Contact the AER editorial office using the details on the AER contact page, referencing your manuscript ID.

No. Eight weeks is early: the AER's Report of the Editor shows about 26 percent of papers sent for review had a first decision within two months and 62 percent within three months (2025 submission year). Reports may still be arriving.

Your paper passed the coeditor desk screen and referees have been invited under single-blind peer review (about three reports per reviewed paper on average, per the 2025 Report of the Editor). The name of the author is revealed to the referee(s), while the referee(s) remain anonymous to authors. The designated coeditor handles the paper throughout the decision process.

Yes, for papers sent to referees: only 62 percent of reviewed papers had a first decision within three months (2025 submission year, Report of the Editor). Multiple revision rounds are common; for articles published in 2025 the average submission-to-acceptance time was 130 weeks.

Past 16 weeks is the right moment for a polite inquiry: about 81 percent of papers sent for review had a first decision within four months, and 97 percent within six months (2025 submission year, Report of the Editor). Silence in the first 8 weeks is normal at AER.

References

Sources

  1. AER Editorial Policy
  2. AER Editorial Process: Discussions with the Editors
  3. AER Reviewer Guidelines
  4. Report of the Editor, American Economic Review
  5. AER ScholarOne portal

Free guide

Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.

Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.

The guide, plus the weekly brief on getting published. One email on Mondays and a product note at most once a month, unsubscribe in one click.

Final step

Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.

The decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.

Free scan, no card needed.

Check my next manuscript

Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.

Re-read the status guide

Put the guidance to work

Turn a decision into a clear next step.

Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.

Internal navigation

Where to go next