Management Science 'Under Review': What Each Status Means
If your Management Science submission shows Under Review, here is what the INFORMS Department Editor is doing during each stage and when to follow up.
While you wait
Waiting on a decision? Get your next move ready.
The wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.
Quick answer: If Management Science shows Under Review, the paper is in active Department Editor or external-review handling; the label does not prove that every reviewer has accepted or that the decision will be favorable. INFORMS publishes service goals on the current submission-guidelines page, but one manuscript can move faster or slower. Use elapsed time, department fit, prior correspondence, and any promised date before deciding whether to inquire.
Evidence basis: We checked current Management Science and INFORMS process sources on 2026-08-13, separating published service goals from Manusights editorial judgment about status and case-specific uncertainty.
Management Science status decision map
Decision layer | Use this page to decide |
|---|---|
Status meaning | Whether Department Editor handling or external review is plausible |
Timing | Whether the relevant service goal, elapsed time, and correspondence align |
Action | Whether to wait, prepare, or make a manuscript-specific inquiry |
Use this page: Start with department, prior status, and elapsed time, then apply the matching action threshold and preserve the dated status sequence before contacting the office.
Before acting: In our status-review work, we trace Management Science interpretation failures across department fit, reviewer assumptions, service-goal misuse, and unsupported outcome predictions.
Next step: Use the process map below and act only on information the portal or editorial office has established.
The journal uses department editors and double-anonymous review.
Use this guide to interpret the management science under review status, decide whether the wait is normal, and prepare the department-fit, methodology, and double-anonymous readiness package most likely to matter if reviewer reports arrive.
For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a Management Science submission readiness check.
Management Science editorial culture
Management Science is organized through departments, so the Department Editor must judge both field-specific rigor and relevance to the journal's broader management-science readership. Papers can remain under the same visible label while reviewers are recruited, reports are returned, an Associate Editor contributes synthesis, or the Department Editor prepares the decision. The productive response is not to decode every day of silence. Keep analysis, code, appendices, anonymity, and a possible response plan ready, then use the published process and manuscript correspondence to choose an inquiry date.
What submission portal does Management Science use?
In our pre-submission review work, what we tell authors watching a Management Science status is that the review can be long because it is developmental: reviewers and the department editor often engage deeply with the framing and contribution, so under review can mean substantive evaluation rather than delay. We see authors read a long wait as a bad sign when it frequently reflects the careful, theory-focused review the journal is known for. The signal worth attending to is the eventual editor letter and its framing of your contribution, which is the part you can prepare for by sharpening that contribution before submission.
Management Science uses INFORMS ScholarOne at ScholarOne submission portal. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID; the INFORMS editorial board page lists Toni Riley as managing editor, and the submission guidelines list her as the managing editor contact. The Management Science submission guidelines and Management Science editorial statement cover the editorial workflow.
How INFORMS handles a Management Science submission
Management Science operates the INFORMS department-based Department Editor model. The journal uses a department-based editorial structure with department editors for Accounting, Data Science, Entrepreneurship & Innovation, Finance, Information Systems, Operations Management, Market Design, Platform & Demand Analytics, and other fields. The handling Department Editor, and possibly an Associate Editor, first evaluates whether the manuscript is a good fit for the department and has sufficient merit to send to reviewers; the editorial statement says an acceptable manuscript must be relevant to the theory or practice of management, meet high standards of rigor, and be of broad interest to management science scholars.
In the journal's process, the Associate Editor recruits reviewers and gives the Department Editor a recommendation, and the Department Editor decides. The Editor-in-Chief handles appeals of Department Editor decisions.
Management Science editorial culture is decisive: the 90-day high-quality-feedback target is among the most ambitious in top-tier business publishing. Papers that pass the Management Science Department Editor desk screen have cleared the steepest filter in INFORMS top-tier business publishing.
Management Science's review pipeline
Status | What is happening | Typical duration |
|---|---|---|
Submitted | ScholarOne administrative processing | Day 0 to 3 |
With Department Editor | Department Editor evaluating department fit + business/operations significance | Days 3 to 21 |
Under Review | Reviewers invited under double-anonymous review | Days 21 to 65 (65-day Department Editor decision average) |
Required Reviews Complete | Department Editor synthesizing reports | 7 to 14 days |
Decision Pending | Department Editor finalizing the decision | 7 to 14 days |
Decision Sent | Reject, R&R, or accept | Check email |
The Department Editor desk screen
Before the paper reaches external reviewers, a Management Science Department Editor evaluates whether the business or operations research significance warrants Management Science's editorial slots and whether the paper fits the department's field.
A desk rejection can mean the Department Editor concluded that the work would fit better at a sister INFORMS journal (Operations Research for operations research theory, M&SOM for manufacturing and service operations, Marketing Science for marketing, INFORMS Journal on Applied Analytics for applied work) or that the Management Science cross-department business research bar is not met.
Day 0 to 3: ScholarOne administrative processing
After submission, the INFORMS Author Portal says an initial administrative review checks that files are complete and meet basic technical requirements, and improperly anonymized manuscripts can be sent back for revised files. The submission itself consists of the ScholarOne steps: the anonymous manuscript as a PDF that meets the formatting guidelines (authors may use their preferred software, and the INFORMS template is optional), supporting documents, a cover letter that includes the abstract, five suggested reviewers and three preferred Associate Editors, ethics certifications (an ethics committee or IRB confirmation may be requested), the AsCollected project page URL for data and code disclosure, and the submission fee. The data and code files themselves are uploaded after acceptance.
The Management Science submission guidelines do not list CONSORT (clinical trials), STROBE (observational studies), or PRISMA (systematic reviews) reporting checklists, since most submissions are business or operations research; the relevant reporting standards are the Code and Data Disclosure Policy and methodology-discipline-specific transparency norms.
Days 3 to 21: Department Editor desk screen
The Department Editor in the appropriate field (Accounting, Data Science, Finance, Information Systems, Operations Management, etc.), and possibly an Associate Editor, first evaluate whether the paper is a good fit for the department and has sufficient merit to send to reviewers.
Ambiguous fit: a different Department Editor may handle the paper
The submission guidelines say the preferred Department Editor is likely to be assigned, but a different Department Editor may handle the paper if the preferred editor's workload is too great or if that editor feels another would be better suited. The corresponding author is notified of the reassignment and can withdraw the manuscript.
Days 21 to 35: External reviewer recruitment (double-anonymous)
Once a paper passes the initial screening, the Associate Editor recruits reviewers. The double-anonymous review model means both authors and reviewers are anonymous to the identity of the other.
Days 21 to 65: Active peer review (65-day Department Editor decision average)
Once reviewers agree to review, their reports feed the 65-day Department Editor decision average the journal states for papers sent to reviewers. The Editor-in-Chief's 'Our Review Process' post says reviewers are asked five questions: whether the research question is clear and important, whether the method is well justified and applied convincingly, whether the results have relevant managerial or policy implications, whether the paper is written clearly, and whether they have other important comments.
Day 65 onward: Editorial synthesis and decision
After reports return, the Associate Editor gives the Department Editor a recommendation, and the Department Editor decides. Management Science strives to provide high-quality feedback to 90 percent of authors within 90 days.
If that decision is a reject, our list of journals to submit to after a Management Science rejection ranks seven next targets by department fit.
When to worry
- Rejection within 1 to 7 days: Administrative issue or immediate scope mismatch.
- Rejection within 7 to 21 days: Department Editor desk rejection.
- Still Under Review after 3 weeks: Strong signal. Paper passed the Department Editor desk screen.
- Still Under Review after 12 weeks: You would be past the journal's 90-day feedback target. A polite inquiry to the managing editor listed on the submission-guidelines page is appropriate.
- Status changes to "Decision Pending": Reports are in; expect a decision within 1 to 2 weeks.
"My paper has been Under Review for 8 weeks. Is that bad?"
This is the most common anxiety we hear from Management Science authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: no, 8 weeks at Under Review puts you right at Management Science's 65-day Department Editor decision average. Reports may already be in editorial synthesis with the Department Editor preparing the recommendation.
If the portal still says Under Review at the 12-week mark, the most likely explanation is that one of the assigned reviewers asked for an extension and the Department Editor granted it.
What you should NOT do during the 8-to-12-week window is email the editorial office. An inquiry at 8 weeks adds friction without accelerating the timeline.
Readiness check
While you wait, scan your next manuscript.
The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.
What to do while waiting
- Do not email the editorial office during the first 8 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
- Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at Management Science. INFORMS has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
- Prepare a comprehensive point-by-point response template for likely reviewer concerns: business or operations research significance, methodological rigor (identification strategy for empirical work, optimization theory for operations research, behavioral validation for experimental work), contribution clarity, reproducibility.
- If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
- Read recent Management Science papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.
- If the decision comes back as an R&R, the Department Editor's letter sets the agenda for round two; our Management Science response to reviewers guide shows how to answer it with one decision-issue ledger.
If Management Science rejects: sister-journal cascade with reasoning
If your Management Science paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the reviewers and Department Editor cited:
Operations Research is the natural INFORMS cascade for operations research theory papers.
M&SOM (Manufacturing & Service Operations Management) is the INFORMS cascade for manufacturing and service operations papers.
Marketing Science is the INFORMS cascade for marketing papers.
INFORMS Journal on Applied Analytics is the INFORMS cascade for applied analytics papers.
INFORMS Journal on Computing is the INFORMS cascade for computing methodology papers.
INFORMS Journal on Optimization is the INFORMS cascade for optimization theory papers.
Production and Operations Management (POMS) is the external POMS Society cascade.
Strategic Management Journal (SMJ) is the external Strategic Management Society cascade.
How Management Science compares to nearby alternatives
Feature | Management Science | Operations Research | M&SOM | Marketing Science |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Desk-rejection rate | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published |
Desk-decision speed | Not published | 1 to 3 weeks | 1 to 3 weeks | 1 to 3 weeks |
Total review time (post-screen) | 65-day DE decision average (90-day high-quality-feedback target) | 90 to 120 days | 60 to 90 days | 90 to 120 days |
Reviewer count | Not published (double-anonymous) | 2 to 3 (double-anonymous) | 2 to 3 (double-anonymous) | 2 to 3 (double-anonymous) |
Peer-review model | Department-based DE + double-anonymous + EIC | INFORMS double-anonymous | INFORMS double-anonymous | INFORMS double-anonymous |
Editorial bar | Top cross-department business research | Top operations research theory | Top manufacturing/service operations | Top marketing |
The Management Science reviewer experience
The Editor-in-Chief's 'Our Review Process' post says reviewers are asked whether the research question is clear and important, whether the method is well justified and applied convincingly, and whether the results have relevant managerial or policy implications. The table below maps those expectations, plus department fit and double-anonymous preparation, to actionable preparation.
Reviewer focus area | What reviewers and editors weigh | How to prepare for it |
|---|---|---|
Business or operations research significance | Does the work advance business or operations research understanding for the relevant department's field? | Frame the introduction around the department-specific contribution. The desk screen selects for papers with clear department fit. |
Methodological rigor | Are the methods appropriate for the Management Science department (identification strategy for empirical work, optimization theory for OR, behavioral design for experiments)? | Include detailed methodology documentation matched to Management Science department norms. |
Cross-department fit | Does the work fit one of Management Science's departments such as Accounting, Data Science, Finance, Information Systems, or Operations Management, or does it span departments productively? | Identify the appropriate Management Science department clearly in the cover letter. Cross-department fit is evaluated at the Department Editor screen. |
Double-anonymous preparation | Does the Management Science file preserve double-anonymous review for both authors and reviewers? | Prepare the manuscript with author-identity removed: no self-citation patterns that reveal identity, no acknowledgments revealing institution, and no appendix links that expose authors. |
What we see in our pre-submission review work on Management Science manuscripts
Manusights review data from this journal family shows a specific risk pattern: in practice, we see Management Science editors and reviewers specifically look for whether the paper has a department-owned contribution rather than a generic top-business-journal pitch. The public INFORMS guidance explains the department structure, the 90-day feedback target, and double-anonymous review, but it does not tell authors how reviewers will read a borderline contribution once the paper is already Under Review.
This guide tells you what Management Science editors look for during the status window. Manusights has reviewed 50+ manuscripts targeting Management Science or adjacent INFORMS, AEA, finance, operations, marketing, strategy, and information-systems journals; full Manusights reviews include a 60-day money-back guarantee, and we do not train AI on customer manuscripts.
Department-fit story is not yet owned
The fastest way a Management Science paper loses momentum after the desk screen is by reading like it belongs to everyone and therefore to no one. We see this in empirical papers that could be Finance, Information Systems, or Operations Management; in data-science papers that present prediction lift without a decision context; and in theory papers that do not say which department's core question is changed.
During Under Review, write a reviewer-facing department map: which department owns the paper, which adjacent department might object, and what sentence in the introduction settles the issue. If that map is weak, run a Check whether your Management Science department-fit story is reviewer-ready ->.
Methodology package is strong but not reviewer-auditable
Management Science reviewers often spend as much time on auditability as novelty. For empirical work, that means identification strategy, robustness, data construction, sample restrictions, and alternative explanations. For operations or optimization work, it means assumptions, proof structure, computational benchmarks, and boundary cases. For behavioral or field experiments, it means design, manipulation checks, preregistration where relevant, and power logic.
A paper can pass the Department Editor screen and still receive a hard reject if reviewers cannot audit the method quickly. If your risk is methodology depth rather than writing, use a Check if your Management Science methods package is auditable ->.
Double-anonymous package leaks identity
Authors often treat double-anonymous preparation as a formatting task, but Management Science reviewers can infer identity from working-paper links, grant language, institutional data partnerships, conference acknowledgments, code repositories, and self-citation phrasing. We see the safest packages use neutral self-citations, anonymized repository links, removed acknowledgments, and a cover-letter explanation for any unavoidable identifying material.
If the manuscript has a high-risk data source or working-paper trail, run a Check whether your double-anonymous file still leaks identity ->.
Management Science Pre-Decision Checklist
- Write the one-sentence department ownership claim and the adjacent-department objection it answers.
- Audit the method package for identification, proof, benchmark, robustness, data, code, and boundary-condition questions.
- Reopen the anonymized files and remove acknowledgments, author-linked repositories, institution names, and revealing self-citation phrasing.
- Prepare a routing plan across Operations Research, M&SOM, Marketing Science, INFORMS Journal on Computing, INFORMS Journal on Optimization, POMS, and Strategic Management Journal.
Source limitations: INFORMS guidance describes workflow mechanics, department structure, and double-anonymous rules; the department-fit and methodology-risk guidance here is inferred from those sources plus Manusights manuscript-review patterns, not from private editorial records.
Methodology note
This page was created from INFORMS's public Management Science submission guidelines at Pubsonline author instructions, INFORMS editorial documentation (90-day high-quality-feedback target for 90 percent of authors, 65-day Department Editor decision average for papers sent to reviewers, double-anonymous review, department-based editorial structure with Department Editors for Accounting/Data Science/Entrepreneurship & Innovation/Finance/Information Systems/Operations Management/Market Design, Platform & Demand Analytics/etc.), and Manusights pre-submission review experience with Management Science-targeted manuscripts.
What to read next
For the INFORMS business and operations landscape beyond Management Science, see Operations Research (OR theory), M&SOM (manufacturing/service operations), Marketing Science (marketing), INFORMS Journal on Applied Analytics (applied), INFORMS Journal on Computing (computing methodology), INFORMS Journal on Optimization (optimization theory), and external top-tier business alternatives (Production and Operations Management, Strategic Management Journal).
The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is top cross-department business research (Management Science), OR theory (Operations Research), manufacturing/service operations (M&SOM), marketing (Marketing Science), applied analytics (INFORMS Journal on Applied Analytics), computing methodology (INFORMS Journal on Computing), optimization theory (INFORMS Journal on Optimization), production/operations management (POMS), or strategic management (SMJ).
Reviewers at Management Science are recruited by the Associate Editor under the INFORMS double-anonymous model. Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any reviewer sees them via the Department Editor model, and preparing a response template that addresses both department-specific significance and methodology accelerates revision rounds substantially.
For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the Management Science cross-department-business-research bar before submission, our Management Science pre-submission diagnostic flags the department fit and double-anonymous preparation weaknesses most likely to surface in reviewer reports.
Submit If
- Your paper has been Under Review for more than 3 weeks and the department fit is explicit in the abstract, introduction, and cover letter.
- Your method section can defend the paper's identification strategy, optimization proof, data-science benchmark, behavioral design, or empirical model at Management Science depth.
- Your anonymized manuscript package has no self-identifying acknowledgments, institutional artifacts, data links, code repositories, or citation phrasing.
If your Management Science paper is Under Review past 3 weeks, you have cleared the Department Editor desk screen. Use the waiting window to prepare a thorough revision response template anticipating double-anonymous reviewer feedback (reviewers do not know your identity).
Management Science submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.
Think Twice If
- The abstract could plausibly be assigned to two departments and the contribution statement does not explain which audience owns the result.
- The methods section is strong, but the managerial, operational, market, policy, or organizational consequence is still implicit.
- The anonymized file still contains author-identifying data repository names, acknowledgments, working-paper history, or self-citation language in the cover letter.
Management Science Department Editors retain discretion to reject after partial review if reviewer reports surface methodological or business/operations significance concerns the desk screen did not catch. The journal does not publish an overall acceptance rate, and its Submission Fee FAQ calls Management Science one of the most selective journals in its field, so most post-desk-screen papers still receive a reject or revision decision.
For a pre-upload diagnostic of business/operations significance framing and methodological rigor, run a Management Science pre-submission diagnostic before reviewer reports surface those concerns.
Last verified: Management Science submission guidelines at Pubsonline author instructions and INFORMS editorial documentation.
Evidence basis
Management Science and INFORMS sources below were accessed 2026-08-13; published service goals are context, not a promise, and case interpretation is Manusights judgment. Department-specific correspondence remains the stronger case signal.
Frequently asked questions
Your manuscript has been through the initial administrative review and is being evaluated by the Department Editor or by external reviewers. The journal uses a department-based editorial structure with department editors for Accounting, Data Science, Entrepreneurship & Innovation, Finance, Information Systems, Operations Management, Market Design, Platform & Demand Analytics, and other fields. Management Science conducts double-anonymous reviews, meaning that both the authors and the reviewers are anonymous to the identity of the other.
Management Science strives to provide high-quality feedback to 90 percent of authors within 90 days. If a paper is sent to reviewers, authors receive a Department Editor decision within 65 days on average.
Wait at least 8 weeks before inquiring. Contact the managing editor listed on the submission-guidelines page, referencing your manuscript ID.
No. Management Science's 90-day high-quality-feedback target and 65-day average Department Editor decision means 8 weeks puts you right at the typical first-decision window.
Your paper passed the Department Editor desk screen, was matched to the appropriate department (Accounting, Data Science, Finance, Information Systems, Operations Management, etc.), and reviewers have been invited under double-anonymous review.
Management Science strives to provide high-quality feedback to 90 percent of authors within 90 days. That is a target, not a measured outcome, and the journal does not publish how many decisions run longer. If your paper is past 90 days, you are outside the journal's stated target window.
Past 12 weeks is the right moment for a polite inquiry (you would be past the journal's 90-day feedback target at this point). Past 16 weeks suggests a reviewer dropped out and the Department Editor needs a replacement.
Sources
Free guide
Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.
Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.
Final step
Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.
The decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.
Free scan, no card needed.
Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.
Re-read the status guidePut the guidance to work
Turn a decision into a clear next step.
Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.
Where to go next
Start here
Same journal, next question
- Science Journal Review Time 2026: Time to First Decision and Full Timeline
- How to Avoid Desk Rejection at Science
- Is Science a Good Journal? A Practical Fit Verdict for Authors
- Major Revision at Science: What It Means and Your Next Move
- Rejected from Science? The 7 Best Journals to Submit Next
- Science Appeal Rejection: Should You Fight, and How? (2026)