Skip to main content

Chemical Society Reviews 'Under Review': What Each Status Means

If your Chemical Society Reviews submission shows Under Review, here is what the RSC handling editor is doing during each stage and when to follow up.

Editorial processThe Manusights editorial team researches and maintains these guides using source review, field-specific analysis, and our documented editorial process.How we work

While you wait

Waiting on Chemical Society Reviews? Get your next move ready.

The Chemical Society Reviews wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.What the status means

Last reviewed: 2026-10-09.

Quick answer: If your Chemical Society Reviews submission shows "Under Review," elapsed time is the most reliable signal. RSC reports a median of 27 days to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions, and 11 days across all decisions, for decisions made in 2025 on full manuscripts submitted after synopsis pre-approval (per Chemical Society Reviews journal page).

Reviewers assess literature comprehensiveness, critical analysis, and novel synthesis.

Evidence basis: Official RSC journal and publishing-process pages establish the proposal route and public workflow. The status evidence log below is Manusights judgment about what one manuscript's observable history supports; it cannot reveal private reviewer assignments, reports, or an eventual decision.

Observable event
What it supports
What it does not prove
Submission acknowledged
The files entered the RSC workflow
That scope or proposal fit has passed
Editor assigned
An editor owns the next assessment
That external reviewers have been invited
Status changes to review language
The paper may be in reviewer selection or active assessment
How many reviewers accepted or what they think
Author task appears
A specific file or response is required
That the eventual decision will be positive
Decision letter arrives
The actual revision, rejection, or acceptance boundary
That every reviewer request must be followed without judgment

Save the date and exact wording of each change. If you contact the journal, ask one neutral process question tied to the last confirmed event rather than asking whether the paper is likely to be accepted.

For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a Chemical Society Reviews submission readiness check. For the broader journal profile and neighboring chemistry-review routes, use the Chemical Society Reviews journal overview.

What submission portal does Chemical Society Reviews use?

Submission portal and editorial contact: Chemical Society Reviews uses ScholarOne Manuscripts at the ScholarOne submission portal. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID; use the editorial office contact listed on the RSC journal page.

The RSC publishing process and editorial policies and RSC assessment and review documentation cover the editorial workflow. For broader status-tracking guidance, the Cell Press author status portal gives useful baseline patterns.

How RSC handles a Chemical Society Reviews submission

RSC says manuscripts are handled by a designated handling editor, who may be a professional in-house editor, an academic editor, or a combination of both, depending on the journal. The handling editor reads the entire review manuscript and evaluates topic importance, literature comprehensiveness, critical analysis, novelty of synthesis, and Chemical Society Reviews subspecialty routing across organic chemistry, inorganic chemistry, physical chemistry, materials chemistry, and chemical biology.

RSC does not publish how many manuscripts a Chemical Society Reviews handling editor handles or how long the initial read takes.

RSC welcomes and encourages proposals for Chemical Society Reviews reviews and asks authors to submit a completed proposal form before a review is written. RSC publishes no desk-rejection rate for the journal. RSC's journal-metrics page says the journal has a pre-submission approval process and that its submission numbers include approved synopses only. Papers that pass the handling editor desk screen have cleared the initial assessment that RSC describes for all of its journals.

What is Chemical Society Reviews's review pipeline?

RSC tracker stage
What is happening
Timing
Manuscript submitted
RSC checks the files for completeness
RSC publishes no duration
With the editorial office
Submission checked for completeness and waiting for assignment to an editor
RSC publishes no duration
With the editor
Applies only if the manuscript is assigned to an associate editor; the editor may reject without further review or offer a transfer
RSC publishes no duration
With reviewers
Starts when the first reviewer agrees to review; the handling editor's name is displayed
RSC median to first decision: 27 days for peer-reviewed submissions, 11 days across all decisions (2025)
Manuscript revisions
The editor has recommended revisions
RSC publishes no duration
Manuscript accepted
The manuscript has been accepted
RSC publishes no duration
Published online
Published as an accepted manuscript or advance article
RSC publishes no duration

The stages above are the seven stages of RSC's manuscript tracker. RSC publishes no stage-by-stage durations, so any day ranges elsewhere on this page are unofficial Manusights planning estimates.

What happens at the Chemical Society Reviews handling editor desk screen?

Before the paper reaches external reviewers, an RSC editor carries out an initial assessment. RSC says a manuscript may be returned to the author without external review if it falls outside the scope of the journal, is of poor scientific quality, is of insufficient general interest for the journal, falls below the novelty required, represents undue fragmentation of the research, or has other problems RSC lists. RSC publishes no desk-rejection rate for Chemical Society Reviews.

A desk rejection most often means the handling editor concluded that the topic does not warrant a review article in Chem Soc Rev (insufficiently timely, already covered by recent reviews, lacking novel synthesis) or that the work would fit better at a sister RSC journal (Materials Chemistry Frontiers for materials reviews, Organic Chemistry Frontiers for organic reviews).

Before writing a review, authors are asked to submit RSC's completed proposal form so the board can give feedback before the article is written.

What happens during RSC administrative processing?

RSC says the files are checked for completeness and that the editorial team will contact the author by email if the manuscript is incomplete. RSC asks for the article text, numbered figures, a cover letter that includes a statement of the importance of the work, preferred reviewers entered in the submission system, any supplementary information, and a data availability statement and conflicts of interest statement in the manuscript. RSC recommends a maximum length of 45 pages for Reviews.

What happens with the RSC handling editor?

The handling editor reads the review manuscript and evaluates topic importance, literature comprehensiveness, critical analysis, and novel synthesis. The handling editor's evaluation is more substantive than research-article desk screens because review articles require evaluation of the entire literature landscape covered.

What happens during internal RSC editor consultation?

RSC does not describe a separate editor consultation stage for Chemical Society Reviews. Its tracker shows the manuscript with the editorial office, then with the editor if it is assigned to an associate editor, then with reviewers.

What happens during external reviewer recruitment?

RSC publishes no reviewer count or recruitment time for Chemical Society Reviews. RSC lists single-anonymised and transparent peer review for the journal. In single-anonymised review the reviewers are anonymous and author names and affiliations are known to them. Transparent peer review is an option authors can choose at any stage before acceptance.

What happens during active peer review?

Once reviewers agree to review, RSC's median to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions is 27 days (decisions made in 2025). Manusights expects reviewers to weigh literature comprehensiveness, critical analysis, novel synthesis, and topic importance, but RSC does not publish a Chemical Society Reviews reviewer checklist.

What happens after reports return?

After reports return, the handling editor weighs the reports against the journal's review-article criteria and issues the next decision. Two reports do not have to agree, and the portal label alone does not reveal whether the editor is waiting for another opinion, evaluating conflicting recommendations, or preparing a letter.

When the decision arrives, separate every requested change into three buckets: literature coverage, synthesis or argument, and presentation. That makes it easier to see whether a revision needs new citations, a rebuilt framework or figure, or simply clearer exposition. RSC publishes no acceptance-to-publication time for the journal, and the post-acceptance stage should not be used to predict the outcome of a manuscript that is still under review.

When to worry

  • Rejection within 1 to 7 days: Administrative issue or immediate scope mismatch.
  • Rejection within 7 to 14 days: Likely a handling editor desk rejection; RSC publishes no desk-rejection rate.
  • Still Under Review after 2 weeks: Strong signal. Paper passed the Chemical Society Reviews handling editor desk screen.
  • Still Under Review after 10 weeks: Reviewer-recruitment or reviewer-report delay. A polite inquiry via the RSC submission portal is appropriate.
  • Status changes to "Decision Pending": Reports may be in; RSC publishes no decision timeline, so treat any timing as a guess.

"My paper has been Under Review for 6 weeks. Is that bad?"

This is the most common anxiety we hear from Chemical Society Reviews authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: 6 weeks is longer than RSC's published median of 27 days to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions, but a median means about half of peer-reviewed first decisions take longer, so it is not by itself a sign of a problem. Reports may already be in editorial synthesis with the handling editor preparing the recommendation.

Delays at a review journal can come from finding reviewers willing to evaluate a long manuscript or from a reviewer asking for an extension, but the portal does not show which. RSC publishes no reason or threshold for delays.

As Manusights guidance, an inquiry during the 6-to-9-week window is unlikely to speed things up; if you do write, keep it to one neutral process question.

What to do while waiting

  • Do not email the editorial office during the first 6 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
  • Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at Chemical Society Reviews. RSC has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
  • Prepare a comprehensive point-by-point response template for likely reviewer concerns: literature comprehensiveness (reviewers may flag missed key references), critical analysis depth (reviewers may request more critical perspective), novel synthesis (reviewers may request additional synthesizing frameworks).
  • If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
  • Read recent Chemical Society Reviews articles in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.

For a review journal, the waiting work is different from a research article. Build a reference audit and synthesis map now: what topic boundary did you claim, which recent reviews could make the topic look already covered, what years and databases did you search, which subfields might reviewers think are underrepresented, and what organizing framework proves this is not only a long literature summary. Reviewers at Chemical Society Reviews can accept a large manuscript, but they will not accept a review that lacks a point of view.

Check whether your Chem Soc Rev topic pitch is visible ->

Readiness check

While you wait on Chemical Society Reviews, scan your next manuscript.

The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.Open status guide

If Chemical Society Reviews rejects: sister-journal cascade with reasoning

If your Chemical Society Reviews paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the reviewers and handling editor cited:

Materials Chemistry Frontiers (RSC) is the natural RSC cascade for materials chemistry reviews. When a paper is to be rejected from one Royal Society of Chemistry journal, authors are offered the option to transfer the paper to one of the other journals for consideration.

Organic Chemistry Frontiers (RSC) is the RSC cascade for organic chemistry reviews.

Inorganic Chemistry Frontiers (RSC) is the RSC cascade for inorganic chemistry reviews.

Chemical Reviews (ACS) is the external ACS chemistry review cascade. Chemical Reviews uses ACS Paragon Plus at ACS journal page; editorial contact chemrev@acs.org.

Nature Reviews Chemistry is the external Springer Nature top-tier chemistry review cascade. The Nature Reviews Chemistry Manuscript Tracking System at mts-natrevchem.nature.com handles submission; natrevchem@nature.com handles publisher-level inquiries.

ACS Catalysis review section for catalysis-specific reviews.

How Chemical Society Reviews compares to nearby alternatives

Feature
Chemical Society Reviews
Chemical Reviews (ACS)
Nature Reviews Chemistry
Materials Chemistry Frontiers (RSC)
Desk-rejection rate
Not published by RSC
Not published
Not published
Not published
Desk-decision speed
Not published by RSC
7 to 14 days
7 to 21 days
7 to 14 days
Total review time (post-screen)
27-day median first decision, peer-reviewed (RSC, 2025 decisions)
8 to 12 weeks
2 to 4 months
6 to 10 weeks
Reviewer count
Not published by RSC
2 to 3 expert reviewers
2 to 3 expert reviewers
2 to 3
Peer-review model
RSC single-anonymised or transparent
Single-blind
Nature single-blind
RSC single-anonymized
Editorial bar
Top RSC chemistry review with novel synthesis
Top ACS chemistry review
Top Nature Portfolio chemistry review
Materials chemistry reviews

Chemical Society Reviews Pre-Decision Checklist

  • A topic-pitch note showing why the review is timely, broad enough for Chemical Society Reviews, and not already answered by a recent major review.
  • A literature map with search boundaries, date range, reference coverage, missed-review audit, and subfield balance.
  • A synthesis-figure plan that turns the review into a critical framework rather than a reference-by-reference summary.
  • A routing note explaining whether Chemical Society Reviews, Chemical Reviews, Accounts of Chemical Research, Nature Reviews Chemistry, Materials Chemistry Frontiers, or a specialist review venue is the correct next destination if the decision is negative.

This guide tells you what Chemical Society Reviews editors look for during the status window. Manusights is the separate pre-submission review layer: we check whether the topic pitch, literature map, synthesis framework, and review-journal routing argument will survive the RSC reviewer pool before those issues become public reviewer comments. Manusights has reviewed 50+ chemistry, review-article, catalysis, materials, and chemical-biology manuscripts, offers a 60-day money-back guarantee on eligible review services, and we do not train AI on private author manuscripts.

Chemical Society Reviews evidence-package check: this is usually not a clinical reporting-checklist page. For review articles, the readiness artifact is the topic pitch, literature map, recent-review collision audit, critical-synthesis framework, figure plan, reference coverage, and conflict-of-interest transparency. If the review is systematic or meta-analytic, use PRISMA; otherwise make the narrative-review method and synthesis logic explicit rather than forcing a clinical checklist.

The Chemical Society Reviews reviewer experience

Manusights expects Chemical Society Reviews reviewers to weigh four things; RSC does not publish a Chem Soc Rev reviewer checklist. The table below maps each to actionable preparation.

Reviewer focus area
What Manusights expects reviewers to evaluate
How to prepare for it
Topic importance
Does the review topic warrant a Chem Soc Rev review article (timely, broad chemistry impact)?
Frame the introduction around the topic importance. Submit RSC's completed proposal form before writing the review.
Literature comprehensiveness
Does the review comprehensively cover the relevant literature?
Include comprehensive reference coverage. Reviewers may flag missed key references.
Critical analysis
Does the review provide critical analysis beyond literature summary?
Include critical perspective on the literature. The strongest Chem Soc Rev reviews offer the author's evaluative perspective, not just summary.
Novel synthesis
Does the review provide novel synthesis (new framework, comparison approach, integration insight) beyond existing reviews?
Frame the novel synthesis explicitly. Reviews that merely summarize existing literature without novel synthesis are rejected.

What we see in our pre-submission review work on Chemical Society Reviews manuscripts

Across Chemical Society Reviews manuscripts, we see three patterns generate the most consistent reviewer concerns and the most common reasons papers miss the editorial bar or fail the desk screen. These are Manusights observations from review-article and chemistry manuscripts prepared for RSC, ACS, and Nature-family review venues, not hidden RSC decision data.

The topic pitch has to answer "why this review, why now, and why these authors." RSC asks for a completed proposal form before a review is written, so a manuscript that simply arrives fully written can still feel weak if the topic case was never sharpened. Stronger submissions make the pitch visible inside the manuscript: the recent technical shift, the unresolved debate, the breadth across chemistry, the missing synthesis in existing reviews, and the authors' authority to organize the field.

Reference volume is not the same as coverage. A Chemical Society Reviews manuscript can cite hundreds of papers and still fail if the coverage is lopsided, outdated, or blind to a neighboring subfield. Reviewers tend to notice when the article favors one school, one material class, one reaction family, one geography, or one author's citation network. The strongest manuscripts make the inclusion boundary explicit and acknowledge important exclusions instead of pretending to be exhaustive.

A review without a synthesis figure often reads like a literature archive. The fastest way to make the article feel like Chem Soc Rev is to give readers a reusable framework: a mechanism map, design-rule matrix, comparison schema, unresolved-question grid, or future-decision tree. If every figure is only a collage of prior studies, reviewers may ask what intellectual work the review adds beyond aggregation.

Source limitation: Manusights cannot see private RSC reviewer assignments, queue state, or editor notes. This page combines official RSC guidance, public timing/status information, and Manusights pre-submission review patterns; the RSC submission record remains the authority for your manuscript.

Evidence boundary for interpreting the status

This page was created from RSC's public Chemical Society Reviews journal page at RSC journal page, RSC publishing process documentation (27-day median time to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions and 11 days across all decisions, for decisions made in 2025 on full manuscripts submitted after synopsis pre-approval; single-anonymised and transparent peer review; proposals welcomed with a completed proposal form required; Editor-in-Chief listed on the RSC journal page), and Manusights pre-submission review experience with Chemical Society Reviews-targeted manuscripts.

Our review of Chemical Society Reviews-targeted manuscripts focuses on the topic pitch, literature map, reference boundary, synthesis figures, competing-review collision, and routing plan authors need while a review article is Under Review.

For the RSC chemistry review landscape beyond Chemical Society Reviews, start with the Chemical Society Reviews submission guide, Chemical Society Reviews review time guide, Chemical Society Reviews cover letter guide, and Chemical Society Reviews desk-screen guide.

For nearby status pages, compare RSC Advances under review and Angewandte Chemie under review. The choice across review titles depends on whether the central contribution is top RSC chemistry review, top ACS review, Nature-family synthesis, a personal perspective, or a specialist review.

RSC says manuscripts that pass the initial assessment are peer reviewed by independent experts in the relevant field. Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any reviewer sees them, and preparing a comprehensive review with novel synthesis is essential.

For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the Chemical Society Reviews topic-importance-plus-novel-synthesis bar before submission, our Chemical Society Reviews pre-submission diagnostic flags the comprehensiveness and synthesis weaknesses most likely to surface in reviewer reports.

Submit If

If your Chemical Society Reviews paper is Under Review past 2 weeks, you have cleared the handling editor desk screen. Use the waiting window to prepare a thorough revision response template anticipating literature-comprehensiveness and critical-analysis reviewer feedback.

Chemical Society Reviews submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.

Think Twice If

Chemical Society Reviews handling editors retain discretion to reject after partial review if reviewer reports surface literature-comprehensiveness or critical-analysis concerns the desk screen did not catch. RSC publishes no acceptance rate for the journal, and a decision after review can still be a rejection or a request for revision.

  • Think twice if the cover letter or introduction does not name the recent-review collision, topic boundary, and reason this review is needed now.
  • Think twice if the reference map lacks a date range, search boundary, broad source coverage, or explicit handling of adjacent chemistry subfields.
  • Think twice if the figures are mostly literature-summary collages rather than a synthesis framework, comparison table, mechanism map, or future-question matrix.

Think twice if the review was written without submitting RSC's proposal form or without topic-pitch discipline. Think twice if the reference map lacks broad source coverage, date-bounded search logic, coverage of competing recent reviews, or clear handling of adjacent subfields. Think twice if the manuscript summarizes literature chronologically but does not offer a new framework, comparison axis, design principle, controversy map, or future-decision structure.

For a pre-upload diagnostic of review-article topic importance and literature comprehensiveness (especially for unsolicited submissions), run a Chemical Society Reviews pre-submission diagnostic before reviewer reports surface those concerns.

Check if your Chem Soc Rev literature map is reviewer-ready ->

Check your Chem Soc Rev review-journal routing plan ->

Frequently asked questions

Your manuscript has cleared the RSC completeness checks and is being evaluated. RSC says its manuscript tracker moves to 'With reviewers' when the first reviewer agrees to review, and shows the handling editor's name at that stage. RSC publishes no reviewer count for Chemical Society Reviews. Reviewers and the handling editor assess topic importance, comprehensiveness, and novelty of synthesis.

RSC reports a median of 27 days to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions, and 11 days across all decisions including rejects without peer review, for decisions made in 2025; these refer to full manuscripts submitted after synopsis pre-approval. RSC publishes no desk-rejection rate and no acceptance-to-publication time for the journal. RSC welcomes proposals for reviews and asks authors to submit a completed proposal form before a review is written.

RSC publishes no waiting period before an inquiry. RSC's median to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions is 27 days, so an inquiry after about 6 weeks is a reasonable, polite option as Manusights guidance. Reference your manuscript ID and use the editorial office contact listed on the RSC journal page. Before writing a review, submit RSC's completed proposal form.

Six weeks is longer than RSC's published median of 27 days to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions, but a median means about half of peer-reviewed first decisions take longer. It is not by itself a sign of a problem. Reports may already be in editorial synthesis.

RSC says the manuscript tracker moves to 'With reviewers' when the first reviewer agrees to review it. RSC lists single-anonymised and transparent peer review for Chemical Society Reviews. The handling editor selects reviewers with topic-matched chemistry expertise, and RSC publishes no reviewer count for the journal.

Yes. RSC's median of 27 days is for first decisions on peer-reviewed submissions, and complex reviews can take longer. RSC publishes no submission-to-acceptance time for the journal.

As Manusights guidance, past 10 weeks is a reasonable moment for a polite inquiry. RSC publishes no threshold at which a delay indicates a problem, and its median to first decision for peer-reviewed submissions is 27 days.

References

Sources

  1. Chemical Society Reviews journal page (RSC)
  2. RSC Our publishing process and editorial policies
  3. RSC Assessment and review
  4. RSC Processes and policies
  5. Chem Soc Rev RSC page

Free guide

Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.

Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.

The guide, plus the weekly brief on getting published. One email on Mondays and a product note at most once a month, unsubscribe in one click.

Final step

Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.

The Chemical Society Reviews decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.

Free scan, no card needed.

Target journal Chemical Society Reviews

Check my next manuscript

Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.

Re-read the status guide

Put the guidance to work

Turn a decision into a clear next step.

Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.

Internal navigation

Where to go next