Skip to main content

Gut (BMJ) 'Under Review': What Each Status Means and When to Expect a Decision

If your Gut submission shows Under Review, here is what the editorial team is doing during each stage and when to follow up.

Editorial processThe Manusights editorial team researches and maintains these guides using source review, field-specific analysis, and our documented editorial process.How we work

While you wait

Waiting on Gut? Get your next move ready.

The Gut wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.What the status means
Timeline context

Gut review timeline: what the data shows

Time to first decision is the most actionable number. What happens after varies by manuscript and reviewer availability.

Full journal profile

What shapes the timeline

  • Use the publisher's current timing summary; do not assume a fixed desk-decision deadline.
  • Editorial assignment, reviewer availability, topic, and revisions can all affect elapsed time.
  • Revision and additional experiments can extend the timeline; the decision letter supplies the actual revision deadline.

What to do while waiting

  • Track the record in the submission portal; a status label alone does not prove external review has begun.
  • Follow the journal's status-inquiry guidance and any deadline in its correspondence.
  • Prepare revision materials in parallel if you expect a revise-and-resubmit decision.

Last reviewed: 2026-10-09.

Quick answer: If your Gut submission shows "Under Review," elapsed time is the most reliable signal. Gut has a 2025 Journal Impact Factor of 24.6 in the 2026 JCR release (ranking 4th out of 147 gastroenterology journals), and its own About page reports a 12 percent acceptance rate with median times to first decision of 3 days without review and 23 days with review (Journal Statistics 2025).

BMJ gives peer reviewers 2 weeks to submit their review, and Gut aims for two external opinions in most instances.

For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a Gut submission readiness check.

Submission portal and editorial contact: Gut uses ScholarOne Manuscripts at ScholarOne submission portal. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID and go through the contact details on Gut's Contact us page.

The BMJ editorial policies portal covers the BMJ family editorial workflow and the BMJ author services article-submission resource hub describes status-check guidance.

For broader status-tracking guidance across gastroenterology publishers, the Cell Press author status portal gives useful baseline patterns for reading status fields across editorial portals.

How does BMJ handle a Gut submission?

BMJ's peer review process runs in stages. The Editorial Production Assistant carries out quality checks, an editor evaluates the article for scope, quality and fit (papers that do not meet these criteria are rejected), the editorial team finds external expert reviewers (and may also send the article to relevant Associate Editors for internal review), reviewers are given 2 weeks, and the editor decides to accept, reject or revise.

Gut aims for two external opinions in most instances, often with additional statistical assessment, and operates single anonymised peer review.

Gut reports a 12% acceptance rate and a median of 3 days to first decision without review (Journal Statistics 2025). Papers that pass the editor's initial assessment have cleared the first filter, but most manuscripts are still not accepted.

What is Gut's review pipeline?

Status
What is happening
Reported timing
Awaiting Editorial Production Assistant Processing
Quality checks; you may need to provide further information before peer review
No published timing
Awaiting Editor Assignment
An editor evaluates scope, quality and fit; papers that do not meet these are rejected
Median 3 days to first decision without review (2025)
Awaiting Reviewer Selection
The team finds external reviewers; for most articles a minimum of two reviews is required
No published timing
Peer Review in Progress
The minimum number of reviewers is secured; if one withdraws, reviewer selection starts again
Reviewers are given 2 weeks
Awaiting Editor Decision
The editor weighs the reviews and decides to accept, reject or revise
Median 23 days to first decision with review (2025)
In Production
The article has been accepted
Median 17 days from acceptance to publication (2025)

What happens at the editorial desk screen?

Before the paper reaches reviewers, an editor evaluates it for scope, quality and fit, and papers that do not meet these criteria are rejected. Gut reports a median of 3 days to a first decision without review (2025).

A rejection on grounds of priority comes with an offer to transfer to Frontline Gastroenterology or BMJ Open Gastroenterology, according to the Gut authors page. Gut's signature strength is microbiome research; papers in the microbiome space are competitive even at the desk screen.

The Gut editorial timeline, stage by stage

  • Quality checks: BMJ's Editorial Production Assistant checks the submission, and you may need to provide further information before it goes to peer review. A complete package includes the manuscript as a Word document with figures as separate files, the reporting checklist (CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA or another relevant guideline) uploaded as a "Research Checklist" file, a cover letter, competing interests, ethics-statement documentation, trial registration where relevant, and the Data Availability Statement.
  • Editor assessment: An editor evaluates the article for scope, quality and fit. Rejections for clearly out-of-scope work happen here. Gut reports a median of 3 days to first decision without review (2025).
  • Reviewer selection: The editorial team finds suitable external expert reviewers and may also send the article to relevant Associate Editors for internal review. For most articles a minimum of two reviews is required, and articles can be sent to multiple prospective reviewers before that number is secured.
  • Active peer review (2-week deadline): Peer reviewers are given 2 weeks to submit their review. If a reviewer withdraws, the editorial team begins reviewer selection again.
  • Editorial decision: The editor takes the reviewers' opinions into account and decides to accept, reject or revise. Gut reports a median of 23 days to first decision with review (2025).

When should you worry?

  • Rejection within the first few days: consistent with Gut's median of 3 days to a first decision without review (2025), and typical for clearly out-of-scope work.
  • Still Under Review after 2 weeks: Strong signal. The paper has most likely passed the editor's initial assessment.
  • Still Under Review after 8 weeks: Well past the 23-day median for a first decision with review, which most often means reviewer-recruitment delay or a late review. A polite inquiry via the ScholarOne portal is appropriate.
  • Status changes to "Decision Pending": Reports are in; an editor is deciding.

"My paper has been Under Review for 4 weeks. Is that bad?"

This is the most common anxiety we hear from Gut authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: not necessarily. Four weeks at Under Review is a little past Gut's reported 23-day median to a first decision with review (2025), but a median means many papers take longer. Reports may still be coming in, or the editor may already be weighing them.

Most reviewer-driven delays come from reviewer recruitment, when several reviewers are invited before the required number is secured, or from a reviewer who withdraws and restarts selection.

If the portal still says Under Review at the 6-week mark, the most likely explanation is that more reviewers had to be invited than planned, or that an assigned reviewer is late.

The better use of the 4-to-6-week window is to audit the revision package you would need if reviewers ask for clarification: abstract priority claim, first figure logic, CONSORT or STROBE traceability, microbiome methods detail if applicable, and the response-letter skeleton. A status note at 4 weeks rarely changes reviewer behavior, but a prepared response file can shorten a later revision by several days.

What to do while waiting

  • Do not email the editorial office during the first 4 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
  • Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at Gut. BMJ has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
  • Prepare a point-by-point response template for likely reviewer concerns: gastroenterology-significance, methodological rigor, CONSORT compliance, reproducibility.
  • If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
  • Read recent Gut papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.

Status inquiry checklist

Send an inquiry only when the elapsed time is outside Gut's normal window or when a material fact has changed. A useful message includes the manuscript ID, submission date, current portal status, article type, and one sentence asking whether any action is needed from the authors. Do not ask for a prediction of the decision, do not attach a revised manuscript unless requested, and do not send the same note separately to multiple editors.

Before writing, check whether the status has changed from "Under Review" to "Required Reviews Complete" or "Decision Pending." If it has, wait for the next decision letter because the editor is already synthesizing reports.

If Gut rejects, what cascade makes sense?

If your Gut paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the reviewers and editors cited:

BMJ Open Gastroenterology is the natural BMJ open-access cascade for gastroenterology papers where the priority bar of Gut flagship is not met but the rigor is high. BMJ's article transfer service moves your files and peer review comments across, and the Gut authors page says papers rejected on grounds of priority are offered transfer to Frontline Gastroenterology or BMJ Open Gastroenterology.

Gut Microbes is the external Taylor & Francis cascade for microbiome-focused gastroenterology research.

Gastroenterology is the external AGA flagship cascade. Gastroenterology uses Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager submission portal; editorial contact gastro@elsevier.com.

Hepatology is the external AASLD specialty cascade for liver-focused work. Hepatology uses Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager submission portal; editorial contact hep@wiley.com.

Journal of Crohn's and Colitis (JCC) is the ECCO IBD specialty cascade.

The Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology is the Lancet specialty cascade. The Lancet uses Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager submission portal; editorial contact editorial@lancet.com.

Readiness check

While you wait on Gut, scan your next manuscript.

The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.Open status guide

How does Gut compare to nearby alternatives?

Feature
Gut
Gastroenterology
Hepatology
BMJ Open Gastroenterology
Desk-rejection rate
Not published (acceptance rate 12 percent, 2025)
Not published
Not published
Not published
Desk-decision speed
Median 3 days to first decision without review (2025)
1 to 3 weeks
1 to 2 weeks
1 to 3 weeks
Total review time (post-screen)
Median 23 days to first decision with review (2025)
4 to 8 weeks
4 to 8 weeks
4 to 8 weeks
Reviewer count
Aims for 2 external opinions
2 to 3
2 to 3
2 to 3
Peer-review model
Single anonymised
Single-blind
Single-blind
BMJ open peer review
Editorial bar
Top BMJ gastroenterology + microbiome strength
Top AGA gastroenterology
Top AASLD hepatology
BMJ open-access gastroenterology

Publisher-reported acceptance figures link to their source. Elsevier catalog figures were checked in October 2026; the catalog does not specify the reporting period or submission denominator.

Submit If

If your Gut paper is Under Review past 2 weeks, you have most likely cleared the editor's initial assessment. Use the waiting window to prepare a thorough revision response template.

Gut submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.

Think Twice If

  • The abstract promises broad gastroenterology relevance, but the first figure and discussion still read like a narrow subspecialty report.
  • The methods section points to CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, or ARRIVE compliance, but the checklist items are not traceable to specific manuscript sections.

Editors can still reject after review if reviewer reports surface methodological or gastroenterology-significance concerns the desk screen did not catch. The 12 percent overall acceptance rate means most manuscripts, including many that pass the desk screen, are not accepted.

For a pre-upload diagnostic of gastroenterology-significance framing and CONSORT compliance, run a Gut pre-submission diagnostic before reviewer reports surface those concerns.

Last verified 2026-10-09 against the Gut About page, the Gut instructions for authors, and the BMJ Author Hub peer review process page.

What do Gut reviewers evaluate?

BMJ's reviewer guidance asks for reviews that are structured, comprehensive, attentive and logical. In our experience, reviewers at Gut look at four things in particular. The table below maps each to actionable preparation.

Reviewer focus area
What reviewers are likely to ask
How to prepare for it
Gastroenterology priority
Does the work matter for the BMJ gastroenterology readership beyond a narrow subspecialty?
Frame the introduction around the broader gastroenterology priority.
Methodological rigor
Are the experimental methods appropriate, properly conducted, and ethically robust?
Include detailed methods documentation. Pre-registration for clinical trials, sample-size justification, and ARRIVE compliance for animal work are evaluated by reviewers.
CONSORT compliance for clinical trials
Does the manuscript comply with CONSORT reporting standards?
Complete the CONSORT checklist fully before submission. Reviewers consistently flag CONSORT gaps.
Reproducibility
Could the central gastroenterology analyses be reproduced by another team with the methods as written?
Use detailed methods documentation. Gut requires data-availability statements. Pre-registration documentation strengthens reproducibility framing.

What patterns miss the Gut bar?

In our pre-submission work with Gut-targeted manuscripts, three named patterns generate the most consistent reviewer concerns and the most common reasons papers miss the editorial bar or fail the desk screen.

Narrow-subspecialty framing flagged at the editor screen. When the introduction frames the work too narrowly within one gastroenterology subspecialty without broader-gastroenterology priority, desk rejection within days is common (Gut reports a median of 3 days to first decision without review). The strongest manuscripts frame the introduction around a broader gastroenterology question the findings address.

Check whether your Gut framing travels beyond one subspecialty →

Reporting checklist gaps surface as reviewer concerns. When CONSORT, STROBE, or PRISMA checklists are incomplete or items say "see Methods" without actual Methods coverage, reviewers consistently request expanded reporting sections. The strongest manuscripts complete the relevant reporting checklist fully before submission.

Check your reporting checklist coverage before review →

Transfer offers. When the editors conclude the work is rigorous but the gastroenterology priority bar of Gut flagship is not met, Gut offers transfer to Frontline Gastroenterology or BMJ Open Gastroenterology (BMJ open-access).

Check whether Gut or BMJ Open Gastroenterology is the better fit →

We have reviewed 50+ manuscripts targeting Gut, Gastroenterology, Hepatology, BMJ Open Gastroenterology, and adjacent GI journals. Full Manusights reviews include a 60-day money-back guarantee, and we do not train models on your manuscript.

In our pre-submission review work across gastroenterology and hepatology targets, we see five recurring preventable risks before peer review: narrow priority framing, under-specified clinical or microbiome methods, incomplete reporting checklist traceability, overextended discussion claims, and weak cascade planning. Source limitation: Official guidance explains the process and portal route, but it cannot diagnose whether your specific abstract, figures, methods, and reporting checklist will satisfy the Gut reviewer mix.

Methodology note

This page was updated from the Gut About page (Journal Statistics 2025: 12 percent acceptance rate, median 3 days to first decision without review, median 23 days with review), the Gut instructions for authors, the BMJ Author Hub peer review process page (2-week reviewer deadline), and Manusights pre-submission review experience with Gut-targeted manuscripts.

For the gastroenterology landscape beyond Gut, see BMJ Open Gastroenterology (BMJ open-access cascade), Gastroenterology (AGA flagship), Hepatology (AASLD liver specialty), Journal of Crohn's and Colitis (ECCO IBD specialty), Gut Microbes (Taylor & Francis microbiome), and The Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology (Lancet specialty).

The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is top BMJ gastroenterology + microbiome strength (Gut), BMJ open-access gastroenterology (BMJ Open Gastroenterology), top AGA gastroenterology (Gastroenterology), top AASLD liver (Hepatology), IBD specialty (JCC), microbiome specialty (Gut Microbes), or top global-impact GI-hepatology (Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology).

Gut aims for two external opinions in most instances, often with additional statistical assessment. Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any external reviewer sees them, and preparing a response template that addresses both gastroenterology-priority and methodology perspectives accelerates revision rounds substantially.

For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the Gut gastroenterology-priority bar before submission, our Gut pre-submission diagnostic flags the framing and reporting-checklist weaknesses most likely to surface in reviewer reports.

Frequently asked questions

Your manuscript has cleared Gut ScholarOne admin checks and is being evaluated. BMJ's peer review process runs from quality checks and editor assessment of scope, quality and fit, through reviewer selection and peer review, to an editor decision to accept, reject or revise. BMJ's Where Is My Paper? tool explains each status in plain language.

Gut's About page reports a median of 3 days to first decision without review and 23 days to first decision with review (Journal Statistics 2025). BMJ gives peer reviewers 2 weeks to submit their review.

Check Where Is My Paper? first. If the status is well beyond the journal's reported 23-day median for a first decision with review, a polite inquiry is reasonable, using the contact details on Gut's Contact us page and referencing your manuscript ID.

Not necessarily. Four weeks is a little past Gut's reported 23-day median for a first decision with review (2025), but a median means many papers take longer. Reports may still be coming in, or the editor may be weighing them.

Reviewers have been invited. For most articles BMJ requires a minimum of two reviews, and articles can be sent to several prospective reviewers before the required number is secured. Gut operates single anonymised peer review, so reviewer names are hidden from the author.

It can be. 23 days is a median for a first decision with review, so many papers take longer, for example when more reviewers must be invited than planned or a reviewer withdraws. Gut does not publish a typical total time from submission to acceptance.

Well past the reported 23-day median, for example beyond 8 weeks, is the right moment for a polite inquiry. If a reviewer withdraws, the editorial team begins reviewer selection again. Silence in the first few weeks is normal.

References

Sources

  1. Gut about page (journal statistics)
  2. Gut instructions for authors
  3. BMJ Author Hub, the peer review process
  4. BMJ editorial policies portal
  5. BMJ article-submission resource hub
  6. Gut journal page (BMJ)
  7. BMJ Gut ScholarOne portal

Free guide

Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.

Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.

The guide, plus the weekly brief on getting published. One email on Mondays and a product note at most once a month, unsubscribe in one click.

Final step

Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.

The Gut decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.

Free scan, no card needed.

Target journal Gut

Check my next manuscript

Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.

Re-read the status guide

Put the guidance to work

Turn a decision into a clear next step.

Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.

Internal navigation

Where to go next