Skip to main content

Physical Review D 'Under Review': What Each Status Means

If your Physical Review D submission shows Under Review, here is what the APS editors and referees are doing during each stage and when to follow up.

Editorial processThe Manusights editorial team researches and maintains these guides using source review, field-specific analysis, and our documented editorial process.How we work

While you wait

Waiting on Physical Review D? Get your next move ready.

The Physical Review D wait is out of your hands; the next move isn't. Scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan to see what reviewers typically push back on, so the revision response is ready when the decision lands.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.What the status means

*Last reviewed: 2026-10-09.

*

Quick answer: If your Physical Review D under review status appears after submission, elapsed time is the most reliable signal. PRD has a 2025 Journal Impact Factor of 5.3 in the 2026 JCR release. APS reports a median of 3 days to the initial editorial decision and 41 days to first decision after review (per APS journal metrics).

PRD uses single-anonymized review. APS does not publish how many referees a typical PRD paper receives or a fixed time for editor assignment.

For authors searching "physical review d under review," the safest interpretation is that the manuscript has entered APS editorial evaluation, but the timing window still tells you more than the status wording.

For a second opinion before reviewers see your manuscript, run a Physical Review D submission readiness check.

What submission portal does Physical Review D use?

In our pre-submission review work, what we see during the Physical Review D review process is that the journal evaluates thoroughness and correctness in particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology rather than broad importance, so the revisions that succeed shore up derivations, documentation, and comparison with existing work rather than inflate significance. Papers stall on incompleteness, not on insufficient grandeur. While under review, answer the technical and completeness concerns precisely and show your work; that is what PRD reviewers are weighing.

Physical Review D uses the APS author submission portal at aps.org submission guidance. Editorial questions should reference the manuscript ID; prd@aps.org handles editorial-office inquiries. The PRD editorial policies and practices and APS editorial policies cover the editorial workflow and status-check guidance.

For broader status-tracking guidance across physics publishers, the Cell Press author status portal gives useful baseline patterns for reading status fields across editorial portals.

How APS handles a Physical Review D submission

APS says the peer review process is directed by a team of staff editors employed by APS and active scientists (academic editors), who are ultimately responsible for decisions on publication and are advised by referees and Editorial Board members. PRD describes its editorial team as Ph.D. scientists with research experience, and its editors evaluate each submission against PRD's scope and acceptance criteria.

PRD editorial culture is decisive: editors may conclude that a submitted manuscript is unlikely to move further in the review process on the basis of the journal's criteria and can issue a rejection without external review. Such decisions, known as desk rejections, allow authors to seek alternative publication options with minimal delay.

Physical Review D's review pipeline

Status
What is happening
Typical duration
Submitted
APS Submissions staff process the files and email a permanent manuscript code
Within 2 business days
Integrity check
APS staff check readability, certain style and formatting requirements, ethics policies, and basic structure
Before the editorial decision
Initial editorial decision
Editors decide to send the manuscript for external review or decline it (desk rejection)
Median 3 days (APS 2025 metrics)
Under Review
Referees evaluate the manuscript; most Physical Review journals ask for reports within 2-3 weeks
First decision after review: median 41 days from submission
Decision
Decision letter: acceptance, offer to resubmit, rejection with an offer to transfer, or rejection without an offer
Check email

The editorial desk screen

Before the paper reaches external referees, PRD editors evaluate whether the manuscript meets the journal's criteria. APS publishes no desk-rejection percentage for PRD; its metrics list a median of 3 days to the initial decision to send for review or decline.

A desk rejection can mean the editor concluded that the work would fit better at a sister APS journal (PRL for broad short-format Letters, PRA for atomic/molecular/optical, PRB for condensed matter, PRE for statistical/biological, PRX for broad open-access) or that PRD's criteria are not met. If the answer is a rejection, where to submit after Physical Review D maps the next venue by subfield, from JHEP and EPJC to JCAP and Classical and Quantum Gravity.

Within 2 business days: APS Editorial Office processing

After submission and processing by Submissions staff, APS emails a permanent manuscript code number. APS staff also check readability, certain style and formatting requirements, the ethics and research integrity policies, and the basic structure expected of a scientific article; papers that fail these checks are rejected without external review.

Initial editorial decision

Editors may conclude that a submitted manuscript is unlikely to move further in the review process and issue a rejection without external review. APS reports a median of 3 days to this initial decision for PRD (2025, direct submissions only); individual papers can differ.

External referee review

When a manuscript is deemed suitable for review, the editors select a number of experts in the research area and ask for an advisory opinion in the form of a report. Most Physical Review journals ask referees for reports within 2-3 weeks. APS does not publish a typical referee count or recruitment time for PRD.

Editorial decision after review

Editors send a decision letter with the reports and instructions on how to proceed: an offer to resubmit (the paper stays active on the submission server for up to six months), a rejection with an offer to transfer to another APS journal, or a rejection without an offer to transfer. APS reports a median of 41 days from submission to first decision after review, 86 days to acceptance, and 115 days to publication (2025, direct submissions only).

When to worry

  • Rejection within the first days: consistent with the 3-day median for the initial editorial decision, which includes desk rejections.
  • Rejection within 1 to 2 weeks: most likely a desk rejection; APS publishes no percentage.
  • Still Under Review after 2 weeks: Probably past the initial editorial decision, since the APS median for that decision is 3 days.
  • Still Under Review well past the 41-day median to first decision after review: A referee-recruitment or referee-report delay is possible. A polite inquiry to the editorial office is appropriate.
  • A decision email arrives: APS sends a decision letter with the reports (unless it is a desk rejection).

"My paper has been Under Review for 5 weeks. Is that bad?"

This is the most common anxiety we hear from PRD authors during the active editorial window. The honest answer: no, 5 weeks is within the normal range, since APS reports a journal-level median of 41 days (about 6 weeks) from submission to first decision after review.

Referee scheduling is a common source of delay at this stage. If the portal still says Under Review well past the median, a polite inquiry to the editorial office is appropriate.

APS says you may write to the editorial staff at any time once a manuscript code is assigned, but an inquiry at 5 weeks, inside the normal range, is unlikely to accelerate the timeline.

What to do while waiting

  • Do not email the editorial office during the first 6 weeks unless an urgent ethics issue surfaces.
  • Do not submit the paper anywhere else while it is Under Review at PRD. APS has explicit prohibitions on dual submission.
  • Prepare a point-by-point response template for likely referee concerns: particle physics significance, theoretical-or-experimental rigor, reproducibility.
  • If you have related work submitted elsewhere or recently published, prepare disclosure language for when revisions are requested.
  • Read recent PRD papers in your subfield to calibrate the current editorial bar.

If Physical Review D rejects: sister-journal cascade with reasoning

If your PRD paper is rejected after review, the natural cascade depends on what the referee and editor cited:

Physical Review X (PRX) is the natural APS open-access cascade for broad short-form particle physics. APS supports manuscript-transfer with referee reports preserved.

Physical Review Letters (PRL) is the APS short-format Letters cascade for broad-physics appeal particle physics work. PRL uses Authors submission portal; editorial contact prl@aps.org.

PRX Quantum is the APS cascade for quantum information aspects of particle physics or cosmology.

Journal of High Energy Physics (JHEP) is the external SISSA cascade for high-energy physics. JHEP uses Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager submission portal; see the JHEP author guidelines for the editorial contact (JHEP is owned by SISSA and published by Springer).

JCAP (Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics) is the external IOP cascade for cosmology and astroparticle physics. JCAP uses Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager submission portal; editorial contact jcap@iop.org.

Astrophysical Journal is the external AAS/IOP cascade for observational astrophysics from particle physics origins. ApJ contact via iop.org publishing services.

Nature Physics is the external Springer Nature top-tier physics cascade. The Nature Physics Manuscript Tracking System at mts-nphys.nature.com handles submission; nphys@nature.com handles publisher-level inquiries.

Readiness check

While you wait on Physical Review D, scan your next manuscript.

The scan takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Use the result to decide whether to revise before the decision comes back.

Check my next manuscriptPrivate API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.Open status guide

How Physical Review D compares to nearby alternatives

Feature
PRD
Physical Review Letters
JHEP
Astrophysical Journal
Desk-rejection rate
Not published by APS
Not published by APS
Not published
Not published
Desk-decision speed
Median 3 days (APS 2025 metrics)
Median 7 days (APS 2025 metrics)
1 to 3 weeks
<2 weeks for editorial rejections
Total review time (post-screen)
Median 41 days to first decision after review; 86 days to acceptance
Median 54 days to first decision after review; 179 days to acceptance
4 to 8 weeks
4 to 8 weeks
Reviewer count
Not published by APS
Not published by APS
1 to 2
1 (single-referee)
Peer-review model
Single-blind
Single-blind short-format Letters
Single-blind
Single-blind
Editorial bar
Particle physics + cosmology + gravitation
Broad-physics appeal + short-format
High-energy physics SISSA
Astrophysics scientific correctness + contribution

Submit If

  • your Physical Review D manuscript has stayed Under Review past 2 weeks and the abstract names the relevant PRD subfield contribution, not only a calculation, dataset, or model.
  • the main equations, figures, systematic uncertainties, code/data availability, and limitations are visible enough for a specialist referee to audit the central claim.
  • the cover letter explains why the paper belongs in PRD rather than PRL, PRX, JHEP, JCAP, Astrophysical Journal, or a narrower theory venue.

Physical Review D submission readiness check takes about 5 minutes.

Think Twice If

  • the title and first paragraph make the paper sound like a technical note when the manuscript needs a particle-physics, gravitation, cosmology, or field-theory contribution.
  • the methods section leaves one key derivation, selection cut, simulation setting, statistical assumption, or data release detail for the referee to infer.
  • the figure sequence cannot survive a skeptical specialist read without extra explanation in the response letter.

For a pre-upload diagnostic of particle physics significance framing and theoretical-or-experimental rigor, run a Physical Review D pre-submission diagnostic before referee reports surface those concerns.

Last verified: PRD editorial policies and practices at Journals author instructions and APS editorial documentation.

PRD reporting-checklist note: most theoretical, phenomenology, cosmology, and particle-physics submissions will not use CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, ARRIVE, or STARD. If a PRD manuscript includes observational datasets, clinical-adjacent diagnostics, animal work, or a systematic evidence review, name the relevant checklist explicitly; otherwise use the submission notes to point reviewers to the reproducibility materials that matter for PRD: code, priors, cuts, simulations, derivations, and data availability.

The Physical Review D referee experience

APS asks referees to assess multiple aspects of an article, including significance and interest to the community. The table below maps four of them to actionable preparation.

Reviewer focus area
What referees are likely to weigh
How to prepare for it
Particle physics significance
Does the Physical Review D paper advance particle physics, gravitation, cosmology, or field-theoretic astrophysics understanding beyond incremental contribution?
Frame the PRD introduction around the broader subfield principle the findings illuminate.
Theoretical-or-experimental rigor
Are the Physical Review D theoretical derivations, computational methods, or experimental analyses appropriate, properly conducted, and rigorous?
Include detailed PRD derivations, code documentation, or systematic uncertainty quantification as applicable.
Reproducibility
Could another team reproduce the central Physical Review D calculations or analyses with the methods as written?
Use detailed PRD methods documentation. APS requires data-availability statements generated from author-supplied answers. Deposit code in public repositories.
Referee robustness
APS does not publish how many referees a PRD paper receives
Referee opinion carries substantial weight in the editor's decision; framing should anticipate the most common referee concerns explicitly.

What we see in our pre-submission review work on Physical Review D manuscripts

Across Physical Review D manuscripts, the risky papers usually have one strong technical asset but an underbuilt editorial argument around it. A specialist referee's read of significance, rigor, and reproducibility can dominate the first decision.

Across our pre-submission review work on Physical Review D, Physical Review Letters, JHEP, JCAP, Astrophysical Journal, and adjacent high-energy physics or cosmology journals, this is the failure pattern we see most often: the result is technically credible, but the manuscript has not made the PRD contribution legible enough for a skeptical specialist referee.

Use this page when you need to decide what to tighten during the waiting window rather than treating the APS status label as the only signal. Full Manusights reviews include a 60-day money-back guarantee, and we do not train AI on customer manuscripts.

Subfield contribution is technically correct but editorially undernamed

Physical Review D submissions often fail because the abstract states what was calculated, simulated, or constrained without stating why that result matters inside PRD's particle physics, gravitation, cosmology, or field-theoretic astrophysics readership. The fix is a sharper contribution ladder: what previous result is being refined, what assumption is being relaxed, what parameter space is newly constrained, and what figure or equation proves the advance.

If the manuscript could be described as "we computed X more carefully" without losing its core pitch, it needs stronger framing. Run a Check whether your PRD subfield contribution is clear -> before a skeptical referee defines the story for you.

Referee fragility is not addressed in the manuscript

APS does not publish how many referees a PRD paper receives, so authors cannot count on reviewer averaging. The manuscript has to answer the skeptical referee's predictable concerns inside the paper: why this approximation is valid, why the dataset or simulation settings are adequate, why the statistical treatment is not overclaiming, and why the result belongs in PRD rather than a narrower venue. We often see strong papers with the right analysis but no preemptive response to the most obvious objection.

If your response letter is already carrying arguments that should be in the introduction, methods, or discussion, use a Check if your PRD single-referee response plan is strong enough ->.

Reproducibility package is too implicit for a technical referee

For PRD, reproducibility risk often means code, parameter choices, data cuts, priors, uncertainty propagation, convergence checks, or derivation steps are implied rather than auditable. A referee may accept the broad idea but still hold the paper if one technical link is missing. Before submission or revision, trace each headline conclusion to a figure, equation, dataset, method paragraph, and uncertainty statement. If one step lives only in a private notebook or in author memory, it is not referee-ready.

A Check whether your PRD methods package is referee-ready -> catches the gaps that often become first-round reviewer requests.

Physical Review D Pre-Decision Checklist

  • Make the abstract state the PRD subfield contribution, not only the technical operation performed.
  • Recheck every figure, equation, table, and appendix against the most skeptical referee objection.
  • Confirm code, data, priors, cuts, simulations, or derivations are available enough for referee audit.
  • Prepare fallback routing language for Physical Review Letters, PRX, JHEP, JCAP, Astrophysical Journal, and Nature Physics.

Source limitations: APS publishes PRD editorial policies and broad Physical Review peer-review guidance; the PRD-failure patterns above are Manusights interpretations from pre-submission manuscript review, not private APS editorial records.

Methodology note

This page was created from APS's public PRD editorial policies and practices at Journals author instructions, APS editorial documentation (median 3 days to the initial editorial decision, 41 days to first decision after review, 86 days to acceptance, and 115 days to publication, and single-anonymized review), and Manusights pre-submission review experience with PRD-targeted manuscripts.

For the APS physics landscape beyond PRD, see Physical Review Letters (broad short-format), Physical Review X (PRX, broad open-access), PRX Quantum (quantum information), and external particle physics alternatives (Journal of High Energy Physics, JCAP, Astrophysical Journal, Nature Physics).

The choice across these titles depends on whether the central contribution is particle physics/cosmology/gravitation (PRD), broad-physics short-format (PRL), broad open-access (PRX), quantum information (PRX Quantum), high-energy physics SISSA (JHEP), cosmology/astroparticle (JCAP), observational astrophysics (ApJ), or top-tier Nature Portfolio (Nature Physics).

Editors screen and triage manuscripts before any referee sees them, and preparing a response template that addresses both subfield significance and referee anticipation can help revision rounds go faster.

For a pre-upload check of your manuscript against the PRD particle-physics-significance bar before submission, our Physical Review D pre-submission diagnostic flags the framing and subfield-fit weaknesses most likely to surface in the referee report.

Frequently asked questions

Your manuscript has cleared APS Editorial Office admin checks and is being evaluated. Editors may conclude that a submitted manuscript is unlikely to move further in the review process on the basis of the journal's criteria and can issue a rejection without external review. PRD uses single-anonymized review; APS does not publish a typical number of referees or a fixed time for editor assignment.

APS's 2025 journal metrics list a median of 3 days to the initial decision on whether to send a PRD manuscript for review and a median of 41 days to the first decision after review, 86 days to acceptance, and 115 days to publication (direct submissions only).

APS says that once a manuscript code is assigned you may write to the editorial staff at any time using the journal-specific email (prd@aps.org for PRD), referencing your manuscript code. Because the journal-level median to first decision after review is 41 days, waiting past about 6 weeks before inquiring about a delay is reasonable.

No. APS's journal-level median to first decision after review is 41 days (about 6 weeks), so 5 weeks is within the normal range. The median is not a deadline for any one paper.

APS does not document a 'Reviewers Assigned' status. If referees have been invited, the manuscript has passed the initial editorial decision. PRD uses single-anonymized review, and APS does not publish how many referees a typical paper receives.

Yes. APS reports a median of 86 days from submission to acceptance for PRD (2025, direct submissions only), so many papers take longer than 60 days. Editors generally offer up to two rounds of review and can add rounds in certain cases.

A polite inquiry is reasonable once the manuscript is well past the 41-day journal-level median to first decision after review, and APS says you may write to the editorial staff at any time once a manuscript code is assigned. Silence in the first 6 weeks is normal at PRD given the multi-stage APS editorial workflow.

References

Sources

  1. Physical Review D Editorial Policies and Practices
  2. APS Editorial Policies
  3. APS Editorial Policies - Peer Review
  4. APS Editorial Policies - Submissions
  5. APS author submission portal

Free guide

Waiting is not the same as being ignored, and there is a way to tell.

Reviewers usually get ten days. When it has been months, an appeal and a complaint are different instruments with different addresses, and only one of them fits a delay. This is which to use, and the wording that gets an answer.

The guide, plus the weekly brief on getting published. One email on Mondays and a product note at most once a month, unsubscribe in one click.

Final step

Done interpreting the status? Put the wait to work.

The Physical Review D decision will arrive on the journal's clock. What you control is what's next: scan your next manuscript free, or run this paper through the scan so the likely reviewer pushback is mapped before the revision request lands.

Free scan, no card needed.

Target journal Physical Review D

Check my next manuscript

Private API processing. Your manuscript is not used to train models.

Re-read the status guide

Put the guidance to work

Turn a decision into a clear next step.

Use the practical response workflow when a manuscript needs revision, or the process guide when you need to understand what the editorial status means.

Internal navigation

Where to go next